Hamilton Advertiser

Lies, damned lies and economists’ statistics

-

It is said: put 12 economists together, ask them a question and you will get 12 different answers.

I have no wish to denigrate economists but their work is not an absolute science.

There are other types of economists who don’t just assess the economics but also factor in political analysis. These are generally more accurate.

The foregoing is an introducti­on to my comments on General Expenditur­e and Revenue Statistics, commonly referred to as GERS.

GERS is gloated over by unionists as confirmati­on that Scotland would have an economic black hole of £15bn with independen­ce and would be poor.

They convenient­ly ignore the UK’S £150bn-odd balance of payments deficit and its almost £2tn national debt (and unionists say Scotland would be a basket case?).

The £15bn talked about is what is considered by the people who compile GERS to be Scotland’s share of this debt.

Much of it is guesswork and contains costs for items and matters we do not have or get. Examples are Hinkley Point, London sewer works, their Undergroun­d alteration­s and Crossrail, Westminste­r refurbishm­ent, salaries/ expenses for 600-odd MPS and even more for lords and ladies and extra civil servants for Brexit.

Why is 8 per cent of the British population (Scotland) accredited with 17 per cent of the UK deficit?

The essential point is the above costs would not exist in an independen­t Scotland’s budget.

I will quote Richard Murphy, a celebrated author, chartered accountant, political economist and campaigner against tax avoidance: “GERS might properly be called crap data.”

Robert Brennan, address supplied

care in April 2016.

Elected councillor­s, who are then nominated to integrated joint boards, will be given the power to influence our health and social care system and make vital decisions that will affect us all.

One in four of us are living with or at increased risk of diabetes. The diabetes community is Scotland’s largest constituen­cy, which is why it’s vital that local election candidates understand the wide-reaching impact of the condition.

People should be supported in managing their diabetes well to help avoid complicati­ons which may result in hospitalis­ation, disability and even premature death.

Diabetes Scotland is reaching out to candidates across Scotland to raise awareness and understand­ing of diabetes. New councillor­s must understand that diabetes not only affects the individual and their family but also our NHS Scotland and the wider economy.

We must prioritise the care and support of people living with all types of diabetes and look at how to introduce new, more effective ways to prevent the rise of type 2 diabetes.

We’re calling on people affected by diabetes across Lanarkshir­e to contact their local candidates and ask them if they will #Stand4diab­etes.

Before May 4 we have to know if our candidates are committed to ensuring that people living with the condition are supported to live health, happy lives.

If you would like to get involved in Diabetes Scotland campaigns please get in touch via Gavin.thomson@diabetes. org.uk or phone 0141 245 6380.

Gavin Thomson, Diabetes Scotland, Glasgow

 ??  ?? Battle for Britain Unionists and nationalis­ts use statistics to support their respective visions of the future
Battle for Britain Unionists and nationalis­ts use statistics to support their respective visions of the future

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom