Man awaiting sentence says he is ‘profoundly sorry’ for causing death of 18 year old
Judge hears of remorse from 32 year old found guilty of murdering teen in ‘street battle’ in Enniskillen
A 32 YEAR OLD man awaiting sentence for murder is “profoundly sorry” for causing the young victim’s death, a court has heard.
Joseph Joyce was convicted by a jury in June of murdering 18-year-old John Paul Mcdonagh, who sustained a fatal leg wound during a ‘street battle’ in Enniskillen in April, 2020.
During the trial, the jury of eight men and four women were shown footage of the fatal incident, which occurred outside Joyce’s Coolcullen Meadows home.
Following a row between Joyce and the members of the Mcdonagh family – who lived at Drumawill Gardens in the same area of Enniskillen – three members of the Mcdonagh family armed themselves and made their way to the Joyces’ home.
In the footage, Joyce is seen standing on the street outside his home.
Brandishing a slash-hook in one hand and a plastic bottle filled with ammonia in the other, the footage captured Joyce engaging in what the Crown described as a “street battle” with Gerard, John and Jimmy Mcdonagh.
The footage also captured Joyce administering the fatal blow to the back of John Paul Mcdonagh’s left leg.
Despite receiving medical treatment both at the scene and in the South West Acute Hospital, Mr. Mcdonagh passed away on the morning of April 13, 2020.
Following his arrest, Joyce made the case he was acting in self-defence and was protecting his pregnant wife, his home and his children from an imminent attack by the Mcdonaghs, who threatened to burn his home down.
He also told police at the time that he was sorry for what happened and never intended to kill anyone.
The case was back before Belfast Crown Court last Friday, October 21, where Joyce’s barrister again apologised on his client’s behalf for the loss of life. Des Fahy KC told Mr. Justice Rooney: “Joseph Joyce is profoundly sorry for what happened and for causing the death of John Paul Mcdonagh.
“It should not have happened, and his remorse is both genuine and sincere.”
Saying Joyce acted with “excessive self-defence” on the afternoon of April 11, 2020, Mr. Fahy said: “The trouble and violence was brought to his door, and he reacted.”
Mr Fahy also submitted several character references written on behalf of Joyce, telling the judge: “Joseph Joyce is not defined by the verdict of the jury.”
Included in the character references were statements from a police officer in Londonderry who spoke of the “positive affect” Joyce’s influence has had on the Traveller community, and a letter from the Traveller Mediation Services that described him as a “peacemaker” regarding family disputes.
However, Crown barrister Barra Mccrory KC urged Mr. Justice Rooney to take into account several “aggravating factors” ahead of sentencing.
These, he said, including Joyce arming himself with the scythe-like weapon and a bottle of ammonia, “willingly engaging in the street battle”, and absconding from the scene.
Mr. Mccrory also asked the judge to consider “the impact on Mrs. Mcdonagh, who witnessed the killing of her son”.
Joyce – with an address at Clon Elagh in Londonderry – is due to be sentenced for murdering Mr. Mcdonagh; wounding the deceased’s brother, Gerard Mcdonagh; possessing two offences weapons – namely the slash-hook and a bottle of ammonia – and a charge of causing an affray.
Speaking last Friday, Mr. Justice Rooney said he would sentence Joyce this week.
Joyce’s wife, Ellen (31), is also due to be sentenced for a common assault committed on the same day.
In addition, several members of the Mcdonagh family are due to be sentenced on a separate date for a variety of offences arising from the same incident.
This includes Gerard Mcdonagh, who was convicted by a jury in a separate trial of attempting to cause grievous bodily harm to Joseph Joyce, possessing an offensive weapon, and affray.