PC Advisor

Corsair One

- Gordon Mah Ung

As Corsair’s first-ever PC, the One is impressive as hell. This tiny machine (which starts at £1,799) is fast, beautifull­y built, and perhaps more importantl­y – quiet, too. That’s no small feat for a PC that measures just 380x200x17­6mm.

According to Corsair, a profession­al lab measured the One’s acoustics at idle: 20dB. That’s equivalent to someone whispering three feet from you. Quiet at idle is one thing. Quiet when the CPU and GPU are at full throttle is quite another. The One excels on that front, too. It’s far from silent (we’ve certainly heard quieter – albeit much larger – machines under load), but we mostly agree with Corsair’s assessment that it would be ‘unnoticeab­le’ under normal gaming conditions.

That quiet is the result of the One’s design and the liquid cooling of both the CPU and GPU. Most small-formfactor rigs out today using the familiar micro-tower mould liquid cool the CPU but leave the GPU to air cooling. Despite having a larger footprint than the One, those boxes just don’t have the room to liquid-cool both components.

Corsair custom-designed the One’s aluminium chassis to hold two low-profile 240mm radiators, one mounted to each interior side of the case. One cools the GeForce GTX 1080 (or 1070 in the lower-end model), while the other keeps the CPU cool. To keep the One’s profile small Corsair has foregone fans on those radiators. Instead, a single low-rpm, 140mm magnetic levitation fan mounted up top sucks air from the system. With the radiators mounted flush with the sides, cooler outside air is sucked through the intakes then through the radiator. Call it a semi-passive liquid-cooling system.

Of course, one fan isn’t enough to keep the entire system chilled. A second fan mounted on the desktop GTX 1080 cools the card’s RAM and voltage regulation modules. Overall it’s quite clever, but not without a cost (which we’ll get to later).

For ports, you get one USB Type-C 10Gb/s, three USB Type-A 5Gb/s, and two plain USB Type-A 480Mb/s, along with two DisplayPor­t 1.4, gigabyte ethernet, and a legacy PS/2 port. VR fans will appreciate the front-mounted HDMI 2.0 port. Wireless is 802.11ac. Finally, there’s a stack of the standard analogue audio connectors and a SPDIF port.

More important than the ports are the components inside. Corsair is offering three tiers at launch, with the £1,799 base-level One featuring a Core i7 7700, GTX 1070, 240GB SATA SSD, and 1TB hard drive. Step up to the £2,199 One Pro and you get an unlocked Core i7-7700K, a GTX 1080 and a 480GB SSD plus 2TB hard drive.

All three versions use a Z270 MiniITX motherboar­d stuffed with 16GB of Corsair DDR4/2400 RAM, a 400W SFX 80 Plus Gold PSU and Windows 10 Home. The operating system is what makes this Corsair’s ‘first PC’ rather than just a box

Corsair custom-designed the One’s aluminium chassis to hold two low-profile 240mm radiators, one mounted to each interior side of the case

of parts. Many vendors sell barebones systems with everything but the operating system, because the minute they install the OS, they’re on the hook for all hardwarean­d software-related issues. Got malware? Problem with the internet? Clouds outside not moving fast enough? Call the PC maker.

So while you might not see it as a big deal that a PC comes complete with OS, know that it’s a big deal for a company that got its start making just one PC component.

Most of the One’s parts are top-notch, but if we were to nitpick, our first target would be the SSD, a Corsair Force in old-fashioned 2.5in SATA flavour. Sure, it’s plenty fast, but with M.2 PCIe NVMe drives offering three to even four times the performanc­e, it’s hard to settle for SATA. Note, however, there’s room for two 2.5in drives and an M.2 drive inside the One. A 400W PSU seems a bit small and potentiall­y limiting for future upgrades, but to be fair, you can’t really drop a ton of hardware into the One’s frame.

Performanc­e

None of these details matter if the One can’t keep up with similar desktops, so we put it through our standard system tests. The results were quite good for a machine so small and quiet.

3DMark

First up is Futuremark’s 3DMark FireStrike Extreme test. It’s a synthetic test (meaning it’s not an actual production game engine), but it’s still useful for measuring a PC’s 3D gaming capability. It’s also generally considered to be neutral ground, free from vendor politics. The overall score reflects the performanc­e of both the CPU and the GPU, but is more weighted toward the latter. You can see the One comes in slightly faster than the 8-core Origin PC Chronos equipped with a Maxwell-era GeForce Titan X. Mind you, we had issues with the Chronos, which ran rather loud.

Tomb Raider

Moving on to an actual game, we ran the older, but still fun, Tomb Raider on the Ultimate setting at 2560x1600 resolution. Again, the One places in front thanks mostly to its higher-clocked seventhgen­eration Kaby Lake CPU and its Pascal GeForce card.

CineBench R15

Moving on to pure CPU performanc­e, we use Maxon’s CineBench R15 to measure a system’s ability to render a 3D scene. This particular test loves multicore CPUs, and systems with more cores generally win.

Although no slouch by any means, the One gets left behind by the eight-core Core i7-5960X in the Chronos. It’s worth noting, however, that the eight-core chip in the Chronos cost a cool thousand pounds in its day, almost three times the cost of an Intel quad-core chip. Still, the upshot from this test is that if you need a machine for heavy-duty 3D-rendering work, consider an octo-core. The good news? Maybe one day we’ll see a Ryzen-based One, too.

Handbrake encoding

Rendering 3D frames isn’t something the typical person does, but for a broader look at CPU performanc­e, here’s how the One would handle a more common video encode. Up against the Core i7-6700K chips in the Gigabyte PC and the Cerise, the One is fastest, but not enough to matter to most users. Sadly, that’s the world of incrementa­l upgrades we live in today with Intel’s quad-core CPUs.

And yes, we again see the Origin PC take all comers by a healthy margin thanks to its eight cores. It’s enough to make us wish there was an affordable eight-core CPU alternativ­e.

Thermals

To sum up the One’s performanc­e, it has no problems hanging with PCs similar (or even larger) in size. There are certainly faster machines in existence, but nothing this small and certainly nothing this quiet.

Still, you have to wonder if the One’s semi-passive liquid-cooling can really withstand a heavy thermal load. To find out, we ran our unit through 3DMark’s stress test for two hours and saw no signs of GPU or CPU throttling in that time.

The upgrade path

Okay, so the Corsair One is small, quiet, and fast. What more could you want? Well, how about easy upgrades? That’s where the price of miniaturis­ation and a custom design whack you on the knuckles. First, getting into the One isn’t a snap, but it’s certainly not impossible. You first push a button, then remove the cast-aluminium top, then remove four screws to release the sides bearing the radiators. From there, you can ‘easily’ access the RAM, CPU, and the SATA drive if you can dig it out from under the cables. As we mentioned before, the One can hold an M.2 SSD and two 2.5in

drives; we suspect the M.2 may be mounted behind the motherboar­d making access major surgery. Swapping the GPU will require a compatible liquid cooler for the upgrade, not to mention time spent extracting the part.

To be fair, this has always been the price of miniaturis­ation. In fact, we’re actually surprised the One is as upgradable as it is, given its size and acoustics. All of the components, as you can see, are industry standard. There’s no weird mobile GPU or strange custom motherboar­d in there. It won’t be easy, but upgrading is possible.

Caveat emptor

Here’s the catch: Corsair says the act of opening up the One to, say, add RAM or a larger SSD voids the warranty. Period. Want it upgraded? An authorised service centre can do it for you.

Why would Corsair do this? Small computers can be tricky to work on. The firm is likely afraid that a clumsy consumer will try to open it up, destroy things, and then scream for a warranty replacemen­t. That’s a valid concern, but we should point out that Dell, HP, and even Apple allow you to add RAM or storage without voiding the warranty (provided you don’t break things). Granted, establishe­d PC OEMs have hundreds of different models and huge support mechanisms. First-time PC-maker Corsair has a considerab­ly smaller operation.

To get the most out of your twoyear warranty, you basically have to treat the One as a sealed box. And for many that won’t be a deal breaker – this amount of power will easily last two years. Corsair also says users can overclock without breaking the warranty.

For more on gaming PCs, see our Group Test on page 60.

Verdict

For a first go at the rodeo, Corsair’s One PC gets most things right. That’s quite an accomplish­ment when you think about all the moving parts there are to a custom design, much less a complete liquid-cooled PC. Corsair just needs to loosen up its warranty policy to make the One truly superb.

 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ?? Corsair uses dongles to route the GPU’s outputs to the back of the system
Corsair uses dongles to route the GPU’s outputs to the back of the system
 ??  ?? 3DMark FireStrike Extreme gives the edge to the Corsair One
3DMark FireStrike Extreme gives the edge to the Corsair One
 ??  ?? The hardware inside the Corsair One schools older as well as cheaper components
The hardware inside the Corsair One schools older as well as cheaper components
 ??  ?? After almost two hours of looping 3DMark, we saw no signs of thermal throttling on either the CPU or GPU
After almost two hours of looping 3DMark, we saw no signs of thermal throttling on either the CPU or GPU
 ??  ?? You can access the RAM, CPU, and SATA drive once you’ve removed one side
You can access the RAM, CPU, and SATA drive once you’ve removed one side
 ??  ?? In our video encoding test, the quad-core Kaby Lake and Skylake machines can’t hang with the older Haswell-E
In our video encoding test, the quad-core Kaby Lake and Skylake machines can’t hang with the older Haswell-E
 ??  ?? The Corsair One’s liquid-cooled Kaby Lake CPU is fast, but it’s still just a quad-core that pales next to an 8-core chip
The Corsair One’s liquid-cooled Kaby Lake CPU is fast, but it’s still just a quad-core that pales next to an 8-core chip
 ??  ??
 ??  ?? Removing the aluminium grill on top, gets you just this far inside the Corsair One without officially violating your warranty
Removing the aluminium grill on top, gets you just this far inside the Corsair One without officially violating your warranty

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom