Scottish Daily Mail

Fury at ‘interferen­ce’ on smacking

- By Jack Doyle

A UNITED Nations human rights panel sparked fury last night after demanding Britain ban all smacking of children.

A committee of experts said the current ‘reasonable chastiseme­nt’ laws were wrong and should be changed.

But campaigner­s said the UN panel – which includes representa­tives from countries with severe human rights problems such as Uganda, Algeria and Egypt – should ‘stop interferin­g’.

Margaret Morrissey, from campaign group ParentsOut­loud, said: ‘Nobody is condoning child abuse. No child should be slapped or hit excessivel­y.

‘But to tap a child when he has done something wrong and put himself in danger is going to do him no harm. There are lots of other human rights abuses the UN should be focusing on. It should stop interferin­g.’

The report also criticised new laws which allow passports to be confiscate­d from potential terrorists travelling to fight for Islamic State.

In addition, it attacked Conservati­ve plans to replace Labour’s Human Rights Act with a British Bill of Rights.

However, Justice Minister Dominic Raab said: ‘A Bill of Rights will strengthen, not weaken human rights.

‘Our reforms will protect our fundamen- tal freedoms, prevent abuse of the system and restore proper democratic accountabi­lity, so that the applicatio­n of human ri ghts commands greater public confidence.’

The UN also complained the age of criminal responsibi­lity, currently ten, was too high and said the ban on prisoner voting should be lifted.

Mr Raab added: ‘As for prisoner voting, it’s for Parliament to decide if prisoners get the vote – not the UN.

‘Frankly, it’s pretty absurd for a UN committee, with various individual­s sent by government­s that don’t hold proper democratic elections at all, to be lecturing us on this issue.’

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom