Scottish Daily Mail

The SNP’s new ally... pompous Patrick, the power-mad green zealot

Ex-youth worker and gay rights campaigner may be kingpin who makes or breaks Nats’ policies

- by Graham Grant

WITH his wish-list politics and radical environmen­tal demands, Patrick Harvie espouses every fashionabl­e, Left-wing cause he can find.

In previous generation­s, he would have been rightly relegated to the fringes of the mainstream political world.

But in the forthcomin­g parliament­ary term, the SNP faces the very real prospect of relying on the support of the Greens – who will exact a heavy price.

Renational­isation of the railways, decriminal­isation of prostituti­on and cannabis use and a tax-grab for middle earners all featured in the party’s manifesto.

Mr Harvie, 43, a former youth worker with a gay support group, became adept during the term of the last minority SNP government at causing maximum disruption to further his party’s objectives. In 2009, the openly bisexual MSP found himself holding the fate of Scotland’s £33billion budget in his hands – and wasted no time in exploiting the opportunit­y to cause political turmoil.

The SNP was then reliant on other parties to get its Budget approved.

But when Finance Secretary John Swinney offered a £22million home insulation scheme in response to the Greens’ demand for a £100million-a-year, ten-year insulation programme, Mr Harvie said this was simply not good enough. On the basis of a relatively trivial disagreeme­nt over insulation, the Budget was sunk, forcing Mr Swinney back to the drawing board.

During the past five years as a more marginal force in the Holyrood chamber, the Greens were riven by personalit­y clashes and a bitter internal leadership election.

Now, with discipline barely restored, Mr Harvie has emerged again as one of Holyrood’s leading power brokers.

In the run-up to the election, the Greens unveiled a radical election manifesto that would punish middle-income Scots, supermarke­ts and landowners.

The party set out a raft of Left-wing pledges, including a 43 per cent higher tax rate for those earning £43,000 or more – up from 40p – and a new property tax that would see a huge increase on some council tax bills. Under the Greens’ tax plans, everyone earning less than £26,500 would be better off and earners on £27,710 would pay an extra £24 a year.

Anyone earning more than £150,000 would pay 60 per cent tax, up from 45p at present.

For good measure, there would be a ‘basket of local taxes’ that could include an American-style local sales tax.

The Greens also want a levy on supermarke­ts if they promote ‘poor-quality food’, which has been dubbed a ‘pie tax’. Landowners were warned they could be forced to sell to tenant farmers, who would be given a ‘right to buy’, while councils could seize vacant land through ‘compulsory sale orders’.

OTHER policies in the Green manifesto included abolishing sanctions for a ‘significan­t number’ of benefit claimants who fail to do enough to find work, the possibilit­y of nationalis­ing the petrochemi­cal plant at Grangemout­h, Stirlingsh­ire, and scrapping funding for new roads.

Inevitably, the party also advocates more electric cars and wind farms despite years of controvers­y over their cost-effectiven­ess and the way they have blighted the Scottish countrysid­e.

Having claimed the credit for a moratorium on fracking, the Greens hope to secure an outright ban.

The achingly trendy Greens are also calling for a ‘women in media’ watchdog to ‘monitor and challenge the under-representa­tion, gender stereotypi­ng and sexualisat­ion of women and girls’.

Yesterday Ross Greer, the party’s newly elected Europe and external affairs spokesman – and Holyrood’s youngest MSP – signalled that ‘finances’, fracking and private rental controls would be the party’s top priorities.

Mr Harvie warned recently that the SNP ‘need to be pushed’ to ‘go beyond their comfort zone’, boasting that the Greens ‘have a track record of making them do that’.

Despite the party’s supposedly ‘cuddly’ public image, the party advocates sanctions against the Israeli state, causing unease among the Scottish Jewish community.

This also puts Nicola Sturgeon in an acutely uncomforta­ble position – she recently warned that some Jewish families are preparing to flee Scotland to avoid anti-Semitism.

The Greens insist they are opposed to anti-Jewish bigotry but Mr Greer has been strongly criticised for voicing public support for Hamas, the Palestinia­n terror group.

It is also far from clear that Mr Harvie, who became Glasgow’s first Green MSP on May 1, 2003, has the sound judgment to occupy his position of newfound power within the Holyrood chamber. A vocal supporter of the SNP’s controvers­ial Named Person scheme, he was one of two MSPs who accepted awards commemorat­ing a gay rights activist who fought to legalise paedophili­a.

It emerged in January 2007 that he and Lib Dem Margaret Smith, a lesbian, both received the Ian Dunn Memorial Award for Activism. Dunn, who died in 1998, was a gay rights activist in later life but in the 1970s co-founded an organisati­on that promoted sexual relations between adults and children.

THE award named after him was presented by gay rights campaigner­s to honour public figures who have worked to promote equality and tolerance of the lesbian and gay community in Scotland.

Mr Harvie was forced into retreat after his acceptance of the award was disclosed, saying he ‘condemned any stance which could be seen to excuse acts of child abuse’.

He called for the award (now discontinu­ed) to be renamed but in 2014 it emerged that the MSP had never sent it back – a decision his spokesman at the time seemed unable to explain adequately.

Mr Harvie was also criticised when it emerged he was a senior figure in the Gay and Lesbian Humanist Associatio­n.

The group believed ‘gay children’ were at risk in Catholic schools, claiming that the Catholic Church ‘hates them’ and is responsibl­e for their ‘unchecked bullying’.

At the time, Mr Harvie was branded a ‘fascist’, determined to introduce ‘sexual anarchy’ into schools. Asked if he would quit the associatio­n, he said: ‘It would be absurd to leave an organisati­on because of one badly written press release.’

Despite these unedifying rows, in the run-up to the Holyrood election in 2007 there was a real prospect – thankfully never realised – that Mr Harvie could be handed a Cabinet post in the then Scottish Executive.

It was expected that the election would lead to a scramble among the main political parties to form a workable alliance, placing ‘fringe’ movements such as the Greens in an extremely powerful position.

Ultimately, the SNP formed a minority administra­tion, but for four years Alex Salmond relied on the Greens to prop up key policies.

Now, with history repeating itself, Mr Salmond’s successor faces striking another similarly undignifie­d alliance to allow her to govern effectivel­y – but one which may leave her credibilit­y broken beyond repair.

 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom