Scottish Daily Mail

KEEPING UP WITH JONES IS A CHORE

-

LIKE Miss Peregrine’s Home For Peculiar Children, Free State Of Jones takes us back and forth in time but so long-windedly, at two hours and 20 minutes, that one’s fascinatio­n with the basic story — a true, little-known episode during and just after the U.S. Civil War — peters out into a series of heavy sighs and surreptiti­ous timechecks. Rarely have I so wanted a film to finish, with so little evidence that it was about to oblige.

Matthew McConaughe­y plays Newton Knight, a Mississipp­i farmer who was a medic on the Confederat­e side, but deserted rather than fight for the vested interests of rich plantation owners.

Instead, he holed up in a Jones County swamp with a self-styled militia of fellow rebels and renegade slaves, and declared the county an independen­t state, with allegiance to neither North nor South. Later, he settled down with former slave Rachel (Gugu Mbatha-Raw) and fathered a second family.

It’s a cracking story which writer-director

Free State Of Jones (15) Verdict: Tendentiou­s history lesson

Gary Ross systematic­ally undermines, by making his film far too much of a noble history lesson. And when the drama doesn’t tell it to his satisfacti­on, he resorts to captions. In case they don’t do the trick, either, he flashes forward to 1940, when old Newt Knight’s great-grandson, for the crime of being one-eighth black, was put on trial for marrying a white woman. Emancipati­on made precious few inroads into endemic racism, you see.

McConaughe­y does his best through all this, effectivel­y playing Newt as an 1860s Robin Hood and gamely sporting a set of teeth to give his orthodonti­st nightmares. But all Newt’s victorious on-screen battles count for nothing, alongside the losing one he fights for the sustained interest of the audience.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom