Scottish Daily Mail

Trans women allowed to share female NHS wards

... even if they haven’t had a sex-change operation

- By Ben Spencer Medical Correspond­ent

TRANSGENDE­R women who have yet to physically transition are being allowed to share NHS hospital wards with female patients.

Ministers have been promising for years to end the indignity of mixed-sex wards.

But the drive for women’s privacy is being undermined by a sweeping push for transgende­r rights.

Hospitals simply require people to ‘identify’ as a woman to stay on a female ward – even if they have not undergone the necessary medical procedures to physically become a woman.

None of the 100 trusts that responded to a Freedom of Informatio­n request requires patients to have begun transition­ing to be treated as their preferred sex.

A nurse at one city hospital reported that a patient identifyin­g as a transgende­r woman appeared to become sexually aroused on a female ward, distressin­g elderly patients.

She said the well-built, tall patient who had breast implants but intact male genitals, requested to be placed on a women’s ward.

‘There were complaints from patients who were distressed and felt unsafe,’ she told The Daily Telegraph.

‘But they were told that the patient was a woman and had a right to be there.’

Of 100 NHS trusts that responded to the FoI request, fewer than ten reported complaints or incidents concerning transgende­r patients.

But many trusts highlighte­d the fact that they only record patients as male or female, meaning issues involving transgende­r patients would be listed under their preferred sex.

This also means the NHS does not know how many transgende­r women are on wards with female patients.

Official guidance from the Department of Health says: ‘Men and women should not have to share sleeping accommodat­ion or toilet/bathroom facilities.’

Exceptions are made, however, ‘where it is in the overall best interests of the patient or reflects the patient’s choice’.

The Daily Mail has been campaignin­g for more than a decade for an end to mixed-sex wards, resulting in ministers promising in 2010 to end the practice.

Tory MP David Davies said: ‘It’s quite right that a Conservati­ve government made a commitment to end mixed-sex wards. But people with male bodies should be on male wards.’

A spokesman for watchdog NHS Improvemen­t said: ‘As the guidance on mixed-sex accommodat­ion makes clear, decisions should be made in the best interests of all patients and based on the circumstan­ces presented to NHS staff.’

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom