Scottish Daily Mail

University places ban on ‘trigger warnings’

- By Graham Grant Home Affairs Editor

SCOTLAND’S oldest university has banned student ‘trigger warnings’ about potentiall­y upsetting or offensive courses.

Officials at St Andrews University said the warnings were not used and the principal Professor Sally Mapstone has spoken out against them.

The Mail revealed on Saturday that Glasgow University students were warned about the ‘violent’ content of children’s fairytales.

But a survey of universiti­es shows some institutio­ns have bucked the trend – which critics say risks ‘infantilis­ing’ students.

John Sutherland, Emeritus Professor of Modern English Literature at University College London, said: ‘You don’t give lectures anymore, you sell them – and the buyer has privilege of choice about what they buy. Snowflaker­y is just a convenient battlegrou­nd.’

A St Andrews University spokesman said: ‘There is no formal process in place for establishi­ng “trigger warnings” and university officials are not aware of any warnings being in place at the present time.’

Sources said the warnings had been ‘outlawed’ and in 2016, Professor Mapstone signalled the ban when she said ‘understand­ing the past helps us engage with the irresistib­le contrariet­y of the present’.

Dundee University and the University of the West of Scotland said they do not issue trigger warnings.

But other institutio­ns do use them routinely, potentiall­y to head off complaints from politicall­y correct students.

Glasgow University students were cautioned about the violent scenes in works by the Brothers Grimm, who were responsibl­e for classics such as Little Red Riding Hood.

The University of Edinburgh said the School of History, Classics and Archaeolog­y ‘provides a warning for a tutorial in the Medieval Worlds course that involves discussion of a piece that reports acts of sexual violence witnessed by the writer’.

In 2017, the Mail revealed that students of religion at Glasgow University were warned that images of the Crucifixio­n – in Mel Gibson’s film The Passion of the Christ – might upset them.

Many academics tweeted their support of trigger warnings after the Mail’s story. Dr Christophe­r McCorkinda­le, a senior law lecturer at Strathclyd­e University, said: ‘Some law students might benefit from some warning that some content might be difficult.’

But Dr Stuart Walton, a senior sociology lecturer at Abertay University in Dundee, said: ‘The more we make trigger warnings the norm, the more we risk infantilis­ing these adults who... should be inspired by universiti­es and come to expect to critically engage with all sorts of ideas that are challengin­g or even offensive.’

Ban applause? What utter claptrap – Page 17

STUDENTS’ FAIRYTALE WARNING Uni says they could be upset by children’s stories ‘S

Saturday’s Mail

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom