Barnett question

In the wake of a victory signalling five more years of SnP stagnation, there is yet another move to modify the constitution by giving Holyrood ‘more powers’. Devo more, devo max or something like that.

The SnP either doesn’t use or mismanages the powers it already has.

The big question being dodged is: In this new ultradevolved Scotland, why would Westminster continue with the Barnett formula? If just about everything is devolved, what case is there for it?

Devo max would bring the same problems for Scots – a lower living standard – as would separation.

JILL STEPHENSON, Edinburgh.