Scottish Field

What's in a word?

-

I read your interestin­g article 'The Blockade Runners' in the July 2021 issue. Was Captain Joannes Wyllie really ‘remarkable’, given that he was supporting the pro-slavery American Confederac­y?

Dr Douglas T Hansell, Glasgow

Editor's reply: ‘Remarkable’ is not a word that is intended to imply praise – as per its dictionary definition (‘uncommon or extraordin­ary’) it simply means very noteworthy. To say that Stonewall Jackson and Ulysses S Grant were remarkable men, which is undeniable, doesn't suggest they were necessaril­y both good men.

SEND YOUR LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, SCOTTISH FIELD, FETTES PARK, 496 FERRY ROAD, EDINBURGH EH5 2DL EMAIL EDITOR@SCOTTISHFI­ELD.CO.UK WEBSITE WWW.SCOTTISHFI­ELD.CO.UK

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom