Top marks for council schools from inspectors
SWANSEA Council has come top or nearly top of the class in many of its education and teaching services, according to Estyn inspectors.
Estyn’s latest assessment of the council’s education service was very positive, although much of it related to the three years before Covid in March 2020. A two-year inspection pause ended in February this year.
How many schools did Estyn inspectors visit?
Between September 2017 and March 2020 they inspected 26 primary schools, eight secondary schools and Swansea’s pupil referral unit.
What did they conclude? Standards were excellent in three primary schools and good in 23 primary schools.
Of the eight secondary schools, standards were excellent in two, good in five and adequate in one. Standards were judged as good in the pupil referral unit.
Estyn said these judgements were the strongest of any local authority in Wales during the same period.
The secondary school judged to have adequate standards was placed into the category of Estyn review, and was later removed in December 2021.
Have there been inspections since the Covid pandemic?
Yes, from February to July Estyn visited eight Swansea primary schools. None of them were placed in any form of follow-up.
What else did Estyn’s assessment of the council’s education service highlight?
It said Swansea schools had a particularly strong record of improvement, with outcomes the strongest in Wales in the three years leading up to Covid.
The performance of pupils at the end of key stage 4 between 2017 and 2019 was above or well above standards in similar schools.
Inspectors also said the performance of pupils eligible for free school meals was consistently above national averages.
Estyn found a wide range of support and interventions for pupils with behavioural and emotional diificulties.
In the school inspections between September 2017 and March 2020, the proportion of schools that received a judgement of good or excellent for wellbeing and attitudes to learning was higher than the national average.
Another area described as a notable strength was the uptake of the authority’s counselling service and the impact this service had on learners’ well-being.
What about school leadership and support for teachers?
In the three-year period prior to the pandemic, said Estyn, most schools inspected were judged to have good or excellent leadership and management a better profile than in any other council in Wales.
The education service has supported a project which enables aspiring deputy head teachers to swap schools for a year and gain valuable experience in a school in a “notably different context”.
Estyn’s report said the profile of inspection outcomes for teaching quality was better in Swansea than in any other local authority in Wales in the three years prior to the pandemic. What could be done better? Although the report cited some strong collaboration between schools for post16 provision, the degree of collaboration involving other schools with sixth forms and other providers had declined in recent years. As a result, the curriculum available to learners was more limited than it used to be. A new strategy aimed to improve this.
Estyn said the capacity for Welshmedium education had gradually increased in Swansea, but provision for early years and schools was not equally accessible across the county at present.
Anything else catch the eye in the report?
The council has a school improvement adviser service, which includes leaders who have visited Spain’s Basque region “to understand different approaches of promoting bilingualism” in schools. They have also worked with London’s Tower Hamlets Council to consider how best to use funds to support pupils in socially-deprived areas.
What about funding and school finances?
Estyn’s report said the council had prioritised education funding in recent years and also capital funding for new schools and school upgrades.
In 2021-2022, the council’s net education budget was around £190 million. The delegated school budget per pupil was £5,236, which was slightly below the Wales average.
There was an underspend in the authority’s education budget last year and the year before, but that followed three overspending years.
All of Swansea’s 77 primary schools and eight comprehensives had a surplus budget as of March 31, 2022. Anything else to report?
Estyn said the council had strong processes for keeping in touch with vulnerable school leavers, particularly in the summer and autumn after they finished school.
The report added that the director of education and her team had reflected well on their work with schools during the pandemic and identified aspects that they were keen to maintain and build upon.
Inspectors also said a review of the council’s additional learning needs strategy resulted in a stronger strategy, with good progress in delivering the actions identified.