The Courier & Advertiser (Angus and Dundee)
When Prince Philip’s poem failed to save Dundee pub
COMMUNITY: Duke of Edinburgh’s verse used in unsuccessful campaign to spare bar in city’s Hilltown 20 years ago
It was the day Prince Philip was thrust into the heart of a campaign to save a “Wild West” Dundee pub from demolition.
The Windmill Bar on Hilltown – which had a reputation for being “a bit rough” – was earmarked to end up in a pile of rubble 20 years ago when the derelict pub was the subject of a proposal to replace it with flats and townhouses.
The long-forgotten building was deemed to be too much of a hazard and, with broken windows and crumbling walls, was labelled an eyesore by many local residents.
The application prompted a campaign to save the building which brought the duke’s old ode to the pub out of safekeeping in February 1999 and to the fore of the bar fight. Prince Philip famously stopped at the bar and pointed up at the windows during the Queen’s jubilee visit to Dundee in 1977, before acknowledging the cheers of the regulars.
In the evening, after the visit, staff and regulars agreed to send a letter to the duke about the bar.
They produced three poems which were copied out on the back of a print of the bar and handed in to the Queen’s bodyguard at Dundee City Chambers.
They were amazed some days later to receive a poem in reply, simply titled The Windmill Bar and signed Philip, thanking the regulars for their welcome.
David McKenzie, son of the owners of the Windmill when the duke penned his ode, used the original copy of the poem to start the Save the Windmill campaign in 1999. He formed a committee to front the campaign, which placed an emphasis on the pub’s royal connections and bombarded Historic Scotland with objections to the proposal.
Mr McKenzie said then: “Saving the pub from demolition is just the first stage. We are now getting help to set up a trust to raise money and attract funding to rebuild the Windmill Bar.”
Some people were amazed by the level of hype surrounding the derelict building and campaigners were accused of being locked in a “sentimental time warp”.
The campaign gathered pace, however, and Historic Scotland dangled a carrot by suggesting the property be marketed at a “realistically low” price for two months.
No offers were submitted and in August the category B-listed building which stood at the corner of Ann Street for 200 years was pulled down to make way for a Discovery Homes housing development.
The duke was not the only ‘celebrity’ associated with the pub.
Actor and comedian Robin Williams also visited the pub several times during appearances at the Edinburgh Festival in the early 1970s, before he was famous.
He stayed in cheap digs in Ann Street which were nearly falling down and impressed regulars with his impressions, including his Scottish accent, which he later used in Mrs Doubtfire.
Williams, who died in 2014, described the Hilltown pub as a rough diamond, but full of characters. Iain Mitchell and David McKenzie bring out the duke’s ode in 1999.