The Courier & Advertiser (Angus and Dundee)
Saints’ semi-final record
Today’s Hampden Park clash with Hibs will be St Johnstone’s 11th League Cup semi-final.
The Perth club have yet to win the competition, having only made the final twice.
Eric Nicolson looks back on the triumphs, the trauma, the highs and the heartbreak.
Included in the trip down memory lane are previously unseen pictures from our archives, previously undeveloped, of Saints’ first ever national cup semifinal victory against Motherwell in 1969.
ST JOHNSTONE 2-3 RANGERS (AET) – 11/10/1961, CELTIC PARK, ATTENDANCE 41,000
Back then there were six group games to be negotiated to get into the last eight and Saints, who had escaped relegation from the old First Division on the last day of the previous season, earned progression the hard way after beating Celtic home and away without conceding a goal.
The quarter-finals were played over two legs and Motherwell were overcome after the Perth men backed up a 3-2 away win with a 1-1 draw at Muirton Park.
The semi-final was Saints’ first in the League Cup and you had to go back to the 30s for their only Scottish Cup one.
The opponents in 1961, as in 1934, were Rangers.
The match at Celtic Park would set the benchmark for heroic failure.
Facing the league leaders, Saints, who had suffered two heavy league defeats to drop them to second from bottom in the top flight table, went 2-0 in front through Ian Gardiner and John Bell.
It took Rangers until 15 minutes from the end to make it 2-2 (from the penalty spot).
That the Light Blues went on to secure their place in the final in extratime came as no great surprise thereafter.
ST JOHNSTONE 0-4 HEARTS – 10/10/1962, EASTER ROAD, ATTENDANCE 25,000
As no Saints fan will need reminded, the club were relegated on the last day of the 61-62 season when Dundee secured the league title at Muirton.
Going down a league didn’t impact their League Cup form, however. Now a Second Division team, they beat a First Division one, Queen of the South, to get into back-to-back semi-finals.
There was no gulf in class in the quarters but the semi against eventual winners Hearts, in which injured keeper Billy Taylor was replaced by youngster Ian Ower, was a different story.
The early-season cup run proved to be a sign of good times to come, though, with Saints clinching the league title and bouncing back to the First Division in one go.
ST JOHNSTONE 1-3 DUNDEE – 11/10/1967 – TANNADICE, ATTENDANCE 18,000
Bobby Brown took Saints to two League Cup semifinals and his successor, Willie Ormond, wrote the next chapter of a burgeoning success story in the competition in his very first season in charge at Muirton.
The stand-out result of the group section was beating Hearts at Tynecastle, which hadn’t happened post-war until that point. Saints won in Perth as well and qualified for the quarters with a match to spare.
Queen’s Park proved to be meek opponents and were thrashed home and away, the aggregate score ending up 8-1.
Avoiding Jock Stein’s European champions was a rare bonus for a club which has been notoriously unlucky in semi-final draws
over the years and beating Dundee at Tannadice was certainly well within Saints’ compass.
Gordon Whitelaw opened the scoring but George Miller’s name went into club infamy with not one but two own goals before Jim Mclean – yes, that one – put the result beyond doubt.
ST JOHNSTONE 2-0 MOTHERWELL – 6/10/1969, HAMPDEN PARK, ATTENDANCE 19,970
It was becoming increasingly clear that Ormond’s team was one of real quality and deserved to smash the semi-final glass ceiling for St Johnstone.
The performances in their group included a Dundee double and an 8-1 demolition of Partick Thistle, which remains a record Saints away victory.
The quarter-final against Falkirk was equally
eye-catching – this time 11-3 over two legs.
Again, Celtic were avoided in the semi-final draw. Motherwell were to be respected (they beat Saints 4-1 in the league a few weeks before the cup tie) but certainly not feared.
The game was Saints’ first semi in the competition at the national stadium and was played on a Monday night – just two days after a trip to Ibrox in the league.
Bill ‘Buck’ Mccarry scored early in one half and Fred Aitken early in the other and Saints’ place in the final, where they lost by one goal to Celtic, was secured with a minimum of drama.
ST JOHNSTONE 1-3 RANGERS – 22/09/1992, HAMPDEN PARK, ATTENDANCE 30,062
After reaching the semifinals on four occasions in nine years during the 60s,
the 70s and 80s were barren decades.
By 1992 the sectional beginning had been replaced by a straight knock-out format and the competition had Skol as its title sponsor.
Alloa, Partick Thistle and Kilmarnock provided progressively tougher opposition before Saints were paired with the dominant side of the era, Rangers, at Hampden.
Had this been the Alex Totten team of a couple of years ago they might have had a chance but cracks were opening up at Mcdiarmid Park and a comfortable evening for the Light Blues was entirely predictable.
Totten’s decision to drop ever-present left-back Sean Mcauley and replace him with Ian Redford perplexed Perth fans.
Paul Wright scored a late penalty consolation but exsaint Ally Mccoist was the Hampden hero.
ST JOHNSTONE 3-0 HEARTS – 27/10/1998, EASTER ROAD, ATTENDANCE 12,027
It is one of Saints’ big ‘what ifs’ – what if Paul Sturrock hadn’t left the club for Dundee United a few months into the 199899 season?
Part of the answer is there’s an argument to say that they wouldn’t have reached the League Cup final.
Sturrock was a far better manager than the man who succeeded him but the key to Sandy Clark’s success was appreciating he had inherited a side which was a well-oiled machine and the best strategy was just letting them go out and play.
And, to Clark’s credit, he took the shackles off compared to Sturrock, who had a lot of the Jim Mclean about him and was sometimes guilty of focusing on the opposition’s
strengths rather than his own team’s.
The lack of inhibitions played out instantly when Clark guided Saints to a stunning 4-0 quarter-final victory against Hibs at Mcdiarmid and it was the very same in the semi-final.
Hearts had won the Scottish Cup the previous summer but they were outplayed by a hungry and focused Perth side, with the experienced men taking the game by the scruff of the neck.
Nick Dasovic scored first, George O’boyle last and in between Allan Preston’s 25yard strike was a goal of the season contender.
ST JOHNSTONE 1-3 HIBS (AET) – 31/01/2007, TYNECASTLE, ATTENDANCE 16,112
Of Saints’ eight League Cup semi-final losses this one (by now the CIS Insurance Cup) was undoubtedly the biggest
hard-luck tale. Owen Coyle was a fearless young manager with a contacts book to match his enthusiasm and had shaped a powerful and effective unit.
To get to this point the First Division side had smashed an Ibrox hoodoo and beaten local rivals Dundee United 3-0.
They went behind early but Jason Scotland’s 76th minute equaliser came during a period of sustained dominance and it was Hibs who were relieved to take the game into extra-time.
Early in the added 30 minutes, Kevin Cuthbert made a mess of a longrange David Murphy freekick, letting it through his grasp at his bottom righthand corner.
Hibs beat Kilmarnock in the final but really didn’t deserve to get the chance.
It turned out to be arguably the cruellest season in Saints’ history. They lost to Celtic in the Scottish Cup semi-final and
then there was the anguish of being denied promotion by James Grady and Gretna.
ST JOHNSTONE 0-2 RANGERS – 03/02/2010, HAMPDEN PARK, ATTENDANCE 17,371
Derek Mcinnes, who conceded the free-kick which led to Murphy’s goal in that Hibs semi-final, was now Saints manager and his team were in the top flight.
There were 11 unanswered goals scored in the first two rounds away at Stenhousemuir and Arbroath, with Hibs and Dundee United beaten next before the long gap until the February Hampden clash with Rangers.
It turned out to be a pretty standard semi for Walter Smith’s men really, albeit a snowstorm posed a threat of abandonment at one point.
Steven Davis and Lee
Mcculloch scored before half-time, with keeper Graeme Smith at fault for the second. A Murray Davidson header was the closest Saints, who were without Kenny Deuchar because of a back injury, came to scoring.
This was slap bang in the middle of an era when it felt as if a cup final was an unattainable goal for St Johnstone. The defeat made it four losses in national semis in three seasons.
ST JOHNSTONE 0-4 ABERDEEN – 01/02/2014, TYNECASTLE, ATTENDANCE 16,761
This was by far the shortest and easiest route Saints had ever navigated to a cup semi-final.
The competition had returned to a group stage first format and because they were involved in Europa League qualifiers, Tommy Wright’s men didn’t enter the fray until the last 16 knock-outs. They beat Hamilton Accies 3-0 and then Morton 1-0 to secure their place in the last four.
The game was effectively won and lost when Saints, who had Stevie Banks in goal in place of the injured Alan Mannus, were just 1-0 down and on top. Lee Croft was through on goal but failed to score with a glorious opportunity.
If ever a defeat proved to be a blessing in disguise it was this one, though. A few months later Saints faced Aberdeen in the Scottish Cup semi and, fuelled by a determination that they wouldn’t yet again be burdened with regrets, they produced the most memorable second half comeback in the club’s history.
ST JOHNSTONE 1-2 HIBS – 30/01/2016, TYNECASTLE, ATTENDANCE 16,971
This was another Europa League-aided League Cup for Saints but the degree of difficulty was far higher than two years earlier.
Yes, Rangers were a Championship side but beating them at Ibrox 3-1 was still a memorable achievement given Mark Warburton’s high-scoring outfit had won 11 out of 11 up to that point, including a 6-2 group triumph at Easter Road.
Morton were again the side vanquished in the quarters by a team now ruthlessly efficient in the cups against lower league opposition.
Saints were in the middle of what would become a nine-game run without a victory and Hibs, by contrast, had hit top form in the Championship.
A soft penalty got Saints off to a dreadful start when Liam Henderson conned referee Steven Mclean but Joe Shaughnessy levelled before the break, only for John Mcginn to become Hibs’ match-winner.
Considering Saints’ cup pedigree, the fact that 2014 had removed the weight of history and that this was the one and only time they have faced a team a division below them in a semi, file it under opportunity passed up.
It has taken five years to get another League Cup semi-final and the opponents will be the same.