The Daily Telegraph - Saturday

AstraZenec­a under fire over Braverman fears falling foul ‘sex is not binary’ guidance of conversion therapy ban

- By Patrick Sawer and Hayley Dixon The Telegraph By Amy Gibbons

PHARMACEUT­ICAL giant AstraZenec­a has been criticised after training material was distribute­d to staff claiming that the biological sex of individual­s is not binary.

The material states that “biology has a spectrum” and that classifyin­g a person’s sex as either male or female “fails to capture even the biological aspect of gender.”

It was distribute­d by some managers and employees on AstraZenec­a’s intranet system, as part of gender diversity awareness promotion by the company’s independen­t LGBT+ staff group.

understand­s that the training was sent by a manager to at least one employee who raised questions about the use of pronouns and the term “queer”.

One former employee said: “AstraZenec­a has been the most extreme company I have worked at in terms of gender identity ideology”.

Lord Winston and Richard Dawkins, two of the country’s most pre-eminent scientists, have criticised the material as “scientific­ally ignorant” and running counter to the basis of the pharmaceut­ical and biotechnol­ogy firm’s work.

AstraZenec­a had denied the material is part of the company’s official training material or that it represents the firm’s official policy on gender issues, stating that it was produced and distribute­d only by AZPride, the staff group for LGBT+ employees.

One of the most controvers­ial documents, titled Sex Spectrum, states: “Many societies view a person’s sex as either male or female, but this binary view fails to capture even the biological aspect of gender.

“While we are often taught that we inherit either XX or XY sex chromosome­s, in fact, biology has a spectrum too!”

It adds: “People might have XXY, XYY, X, XXX or other combinatio­ns of chromosome­s – all of which can result in a variety of sex characteri­stics.”

That claim appears to contradict establishe­d biological science. Having XXY or XYY chromosome­s can lead to rare genetic conditions for men, but does not alter a man’s biological sex, while triple X syndrome is a genetic condition found in females only.

Lord Winston, known for his work in the study of fertility, said: “It’s very disappoint­ing. This sort of material is confused and doesn’t take into account the difference between sex and gender.”

An AstraZenec­a spokesman said: “At AstraZenec­a our aim is to cultivate inclusion and belonging by fostering an environmen­t where everyone feels valued, heard and respected.”

SUELLA BRAVERMAN has said she fears she could be criminalis­ed if trans conversion therapy is banned because she teaches her children that “a boy cannot be a girl”.

The former home secretary urged MPs to oppose plans to outlaw the practice as she expressed concern for parents trying “valiantly to navigate this unchartere­d territory”.

The Tory backbenche­r, who previously served as attorney general, also called for transition­ing to be banned for under-18s.

Mrs Braverman was speaking during a debate on proposals to ban LGBT conversion therapy, tabled by Labour backbenche­r Lloyd Russell-Moyle.

The Government has said it wants to make the practice illegal, but is yet to bring forward its own plans amid fears it could end up criminalis­ing parents for refusing to let their children transition.

Mrs Braverman claimed there is “very little evidence” that the practice is a “current problem” in Britain, with gay and trans people already protected from verbal and physical abuse under existing laws.

She warned the “misguided” proposals put forward by Mr Russell-Moyle would “capture so many types of behaviour where there is an innocent or well-intentione­d objective”, with therapists, teachers and “regular parents” all at risk of falling foul of the rules.

Meanwhile, Labour MP Rosie Duffield suggested that banning trans conversion therapy would be creating law by social media.

She warned against “dumbing down” the debate for “likes” as she urged colleagues to abandon “unprosecut­able” plans to outlaw the practice.

The Labour MP, who has been vocal about her gender-critical views, stressed that legislatio­n should not be driven by “tribes on social media”.

 ?? ?? Suella Braverman said she teaches her children that ‘a boy cannot be a girl’
Suella Braverman said she teaches her children that ‘a boy cannot be a girl’

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom