Events before Nora’s death don’t add up, say family
Teenager’s body was found in spot that had already been searched, raising suspicions she was abducted and later put there
Nora Quoirin’s parents did not have to say that their hearts were broken over her terrible death in an unforgiving Malaysian jungle. For days, the horror of losing their eldest child in mystifying circumstances in a country far from home had been etched on their agonised faces.
The 15-year-old’s body’s was found on Tuesday and brought a final, painful end to the question of what had happened to her nine days after she disappeared from her Franco-irish family’s holiday villa in the Dusun eco-resort, some 40 miles from Malaysia’s capital, Kuala Lumpur.
Nora was found by volunteer searchers, without clothes and lying in a sleeping pose, in a stream in a ravine near a remote jungle waterfall 1.5 miles from the resort.
A local post-mortem examination, observed by foreign experts, concluded that the teenager died after “bleeding in her intestines due to not eating” as well as “extreme stress”, ruling out the suspicion of foul play.
But her Irish mother Meabh, 45, and French father Sebastien, 47, remain tormented by unanswered questions about the facts surrounding her death. The brutal reality is that the true story may never be known.
“The initial post-mortem results have given some information that help us to understand Nora’s cause of death,” her family said last night through Sankana Nair, their Malaysian lawyer.
“But our beautiful innocent girl died in extremely complex circumstances and we are hoping that soon we will have more answers to our many questions. We are still struggling to understand the events of the last 10 days.” Nora’s wider family have gone further, openly suggesting she was the victim of a crime.
“The findings that were announced in no way discredit a criminal act. She could have been kidnapped and fed at the beginning. There is insufficient evidence to jump to definitive conclusions,” her uncle Pacome Quoirin, a French graphic designer, told the Irish Times.
The tragedy began on the first day of the “holiday of a lifetime” for the Quoirin family of five, who on Aug 3 had made the exhausting 18-hour-trip from their London home to the tranquil surroundings of the Dusun hotel, an orchard resort on the edge of a tropical rainforest.
Early on their first day, Sebastien Quoirin realised Nora was missing from her bedroom – a heart-stopping moment compounded by the unique vulnerability of his daughter. She was born with holoprosencephaly, a neurological disorder that limited her speech and coordination.
She had undergone several operations in infancy to enable her to breathe and attended a school for children with special needs; her independence had always been limited. Mr Quoirin immediately called the police. An open hall window on the ground floor of the duplex bungalow, Nora’s obvious exit point, became an immediate focus of the police investigation. It was reportedly broken and could have been opened from the inside or outside. The police lifted fingerprints although no identity was ever revealed.
But did Nora, disorientated by jet lag, step outside into darkness of her own volition, or was she forced or lured by someone else?
For her family, the answer is clear – Nora would never have left her family of her own free will.
“Her family was her entire universe,” her grandfather Sylvain Quoirin, the mayor of a small town in Burgundy told the Irish Times. “She was very sensitive, shy, inhibited, introverted. She became anguished if her family weren’t present. She clung
‘Can you imagine her walking 2.5km, naked and barefoot, over rocks, in the middle of the night? For me, that’s absurd’
to her parents and sister. She would not have willingly left with a stranger. If she went out alone by mistake, she would have banged on the door and screamed to be let back in.”
From the start, Nora’s distraught family have urged the Royal Malaysian police force to consider the case a “criminal matter”, but investigating officers have stuck by their decision to treat the disappearance as a missing person investigation, citing a lack of evidence for the criminal element.
The Quoirins have openly expressed their gratitude to the 350 local volunteers and police officers who fanned out across the perilous terrain, in hot and humid conditions, to search for their child.
But the family’s frustration has still been evident, not least because of their deep conviction that Nora’s physical challenges would have made it impossible for her to wander barefoot through deep, undulating forest, and up the steep path to the ravine where she was found.
“Can you imagine her walking 2.5km, naked and barefoot, over rocks, in the middle of the night? For me, that’s absurd,” said her grandfather.
The post-mortem examination ruled that the teenager had died two to three days before her body was found, deepening doubts about how she could have survived for so long on her own. But the elder Mr Quoirin also raises another troubling question that hangs over the search that had deployed drones with thermal detection capabilities from the first day, and drafted in a special forces unit by the end of the first week. The body was found in an area that had previously been searched, admitted Mazn Mazlan, the deputy inspector general of police. Nora was eventually discovered by a 24-strong volunteer hiking team, reportedly alerted by a strong smell and a tip-off about the location. Mr Quoirin believes someone put Nora’s body in the stream “to get rid of her”, adding: “She wasn’t there yet [during previous searches]. Someone put her there.”
The disturbing theory was also raised by the family’s spokesman, Matthew Searle, of the
Lucie Blackman Trust, who confirmed that the family still had a “large amount of questions”.
He said: “One of those questions is, has the body been there all the time or is there a criminal involvement? Was the body dumped there afterwards?” Charles Morel, the family’s French lawyer, added to the scepticism. “We want to make sure not only that this [criminal] hypothesis is not ruled out, but that [the investigators] work on it … taking into account the importance of tourism in Malaysia and its image, the authorities may tend to prioritise the thesis that she left [voluntarily] over the criminal hypothesis,” he told The Daily Telegraph. Other open questions include the mystery of Nora’s clothes – why was the young girl naked given that she was wearing underwear on the night she went missing? Have the police found her clothes in the jungle? And for a teenager so close to her family, why did she not respond to the heartbreaking recorded pleas of her mother that were broadcast over the jungle area, pleading: “Nora, darling, Nora, I love you, Mum is here.”
Still, throughout their ordeal the Quoirins have remained dignified in their gratitude to the Malaysian search team and eloquent in their grief.
“She is the truest, most precious girl and we love her infinitely. The cruelty of her being taken away is unbearable. Our hearts are broken,” they said.
Yesterday, after receiving a visit from Wan Azizah Ismail, the country’s deputy prime minister, they repeated their thanks to the Malaysian authorities for their support and said: “We will be bringing Nora home where she will finally be laid to rest, close to her loving families in France and Ireland.”