Hospital drama exposes the hardships of working mums
This Is Going to Hurt was an accomplished TV drama, based on a hit book and featuring a typically excellent performance from Ben Whishaw, but it had two faults. The first was the streak of misogyny that ran through Adam Kay’s writing (come back to me when you’ve been through childbirth yourself, pal) and the second was a rather lofty sense that the show had Important Things to Say about politics and the NHS.
So hurrah for Maternal (ITV1/ ITVX), which is also about harried doctors in a busy hospital, but does not have the above problems. It’s a wittier show with much more of a focus on the personal lives of its main characters – if you loved The Split, then you’ll love this – and the three leads are women.
Maryam (Parminder Nagra), Helen (Lisa Mcgrillis) and Catherine (Lara Pulver) have all just returned from maternity leave. While this is a hospital drama, their experiences will chime with any woman going back to work. There is a great opening scene of the three doing nursery drop-off on their first day back, and Maryam ( just before securing the button of her trousers with a hairband to make them do up) asking: “What if I hate being away from them? Or love being away from them – that’s worse, right?” I don’t know whether all of the details in this
show are accurate – the writer, Jacqui Honess-martin, has no medical background – but when it comes to the anxieties of women returning to the workplace, she’s bang on, having developed the show following her own experience of returning to her job full-time after maternity leave.
Nagra can do the doctor stuff with her eyes shut, having appeared in
ER for years. Here she’s playing a paediatric registrar, a job now made more testing by the fact she has become a parent herself. Helen is in acute medicine, working with her husband and – awkward – the junior doctor with whom he’s been having an affair. Catherine is a surgeon and single parent who has, until now, run her life with sleek efficiency.
If you’re a man of a sensitive disposition then you may want to give Maternal a miss, because every male character here is a smug, entitled a--e. As a signifier, Helen’s husband is played by the same actor (Oliver Chris) who plays Anna Maxwell Martin’s uninvolved husband in the similarly themed Motherland. Occasionally it gets overly soapy – Catherine telling a colleague that he’s the father of the baby she had nine months ago – but it’s mostly smart and funny, and the medical drama moments can be surprisingly hard-hitting.
Mayor of Kingstown (Paramount+) is not to be confused with Mare of Easttown. Once you start watching them, the differences are obvious. Mare of Easttown had a capable woman in the lead role, played by the capable Kate Winslet. In Mayor of Kingstown,
the women are hookers, incapable of doing anything without a man’s help.
This is macho TV, the calling card of show creator Taylor Sheridan, a former cowboy who has enjoyed huge success in the US with Yellowstone. Jeremy Renner plays Mike Mclusky, not a real mayor but so-called because he is the Mr Fix-it of a grim Michigan town dominated by seven prisons. Renner (currently recovering from a terrible snow plough accident) is in cool, tough guy mode, as respected by the police as he is by gangsters. He has rescued the sweet-but-damaged prostitute sent to snare him in series one, because men like this are always saviours and protectors. If only Mike drove a Lamborghini, this would be a teenage boy’s fantasy.
The show is aiming for the dramatic heights of The Wire and The Shield but falls short. The performances are decent – particularly Taylor Handley as Mike’s police officer brother – and the plotting is assured. But it is undone by the violence for violence’s sake. Drug-dealing gangsters, prison guards, police – no matter who is on screen, they’re either shooting people in the head or beating them half to death.
You sense that the makers have brainstormed how to shock/titillate viewers further: in one scene, a gang ambushes a car then lets their pit bull jump in and maul the driver to death. The police come along and pump 15 bullets into the dog. Series one ended with a riot; in series two we learn that the inmates killed 33 guards and “raped the rest of them with their own billy clubs”, and are now housed in a camp where lawlessness reigns.
As for the women? Dianne Wiest, the only female allowed to keep her clothes on, is coshed by a mugger. Things are going better for Mike’s prostitute pal when he installs her on a boat and – what are the chances? – she finds a string bikini in exactly her size.
Maternal ★★★★ Mayor of Kingstown ★★