The Daily Telegraph

The obsession with Shamima Begum needs to stop now

- Anita Singh

Another day, another opportunit­y to hear Isil’s most famous recruit give her version of events. The Shamima Begum Story (BBC Two) is a documentar­y accompanyi­ng a 10-part BBC podcast. “For the first time, she’s given her account of what happened over the last eight years,” we were told. Yet hasn’t she also told her story to news reporters and broadcaste­rs, not to mention a 2021 Sky documentar­y? And aren’t we past caring?

We learned nothing new here. The podcast has been most notable so far for Begum revealing that she took a supply of Mint Aeros with her to Syria, concerned that they wouldn’t be available, but that didn’t make the cut for this 90-minute film.

Begum, the Bethnal Green schoolgirl who ran off to join Islamic State aged 15, is now 23. She remains a mass of contradict­ions. A thoroughly silly girl, and yet not stupid – certainly, she is clever enough to be evasive on certain topics. She complains of feeling oppressed by her strict parents and denied the freedom of other teenagers, so why join a society in which women were little more than chattels? When Begum arrived in Syria, she was put in a house with 100 other women; their only way out was to be married off to an Isil fighter, for the purposes of breeding. “It almost felt like prostituti­on,” she said.

Film-maker Josh Baker put question after question to Begum, who had been instructed to direct all her answers straight into the camera.

In all her years of being interviewe­d, Begum’s manner has remained the same: a mixture of insolence and vulnerabil­ity, with some of her statements carrying a ring of truth and others causing us to doubt her words. She now claims to feel shame and guilt, but it is impossible to gauge whether this is genuine.

Baker interviewe­d others involved in her story. They included her husband, a Dutch Isil fighter who is patently a nasty piece of work. I would have liked to hear from Begum’s parents, but they did not appear.

Begum’s story raises the important subject of why young people, born and raised in Britain, can feel so alienated from wider society that they are radicalise­d in this way; why living “a good Islamic life” in Syria, as she described it, would be preferable to life in east London. But the film touched on that only briefly. Instead, it chose to continue the media’s obsession with this one individual. Even Begum rolled her eyes at the number of journalist­s who had queued up to interview her. “They just wanted to continue the story,” she sighed.

Sexual harassment is a normal part of school life. That was the conclusion of an Ofsted report a couple of years ago and is the starting point for Consent (Channel 4), a one-off drama set in a private school.

Perhaps it was ever thus, although the school I attended was superficia­lly similar to this fictional one – a mostly middle-class intake, traditiona­lly an all-boys establishm­ent but with girls latterly admitted to the Sixth Form – and there was no behaviour of the kind depicted here. Crucially, though, I went to school before the invention of mobile phones.

Phones provide unfettered access to pornograph­y, warping teenagers’ views of what consensual sex should look like, and to Whatsapp/snapchat groups in which boys can give free expression to their worst instincts. It is a toxic combinatio­n. Added to that is the threat of sexual encounters being recorded and circulated. Who would want to be a teenager now?

Archie (a strong performanc­e from newcomer Tom Victor) seems to be one of the more decent members of his friendship group. He is attracted to Natalie (Lashay Anderson), a workingcla­ss girl who got into the school on a bursary and worries that she doesn’t fit in. But she is the best friend of Archie’s twin sister; it is at the siblings’ 18th birthday party that Archie and Natalie end up in an encounter which he insists was consensual and she insists was rape because she was too drunk.

The subject matter is important, and shows addressing it should be required viewing for teenage boys and girls. This particular drama does feel very basic, though, painted in broad brush strokes to fit into its hour-long running time. The set-up – sensitive rich boy, smart girl from a humble background – is straight out of the 1980s film Pretty in Pink, right down to the insufferab­le blond kid who dominates the group (a particular­ly cartoonish character).

The fact that most of these actors are older than school age takes away from the authentici­ty, as does the decision to have the cast act out their Whatsapp discussion­s. It feels stagey. The ending acts as a warning that even the “nice” boys can be guilty of behaving like this.

The Shamima Begum Story ★★ Consent ★★★

 ?? ??
 ?? ?? A BBC documentar­y failed to explore the bigger issues of Jihadi recruitmen­t
A BBC documentar­y failed to explore the bigger issues of Jihadi recruitmen­t

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom