The Guardian

‘Wholly unsafe’ Dubai suspected after sheikh’s ex-wife found in database

Details of close aides and friends also found after Princess Haya moved to UK in 2019

- David Pegg and Paul Lewis

As her plane touched down in April 2019, Princess Haya bint al-Hussein, who was accompanie­d by her two children, might have hoped she was beyond the reach of her ex-husband, the emir of Dubai, Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid al-Maktoum.

Similarly, when he commenced custody proceeding­s in the high court of justice the following month, she might have imagined that the dispute would be settled in an English courtroom, purely on the basis of its legal merits.

She did not know, however, that it was likely that mobile phone numbers belonging to her closest aides, advisers and friends were being entered into a system operated by agents of the emirate of Dubai, one of the clients of the spyware manufactur­er NSO Group.

The phone numbers of Haya, and eight of her close associates, appear in a dataset believed to indicate people of interest to a government client of NSO. That data has been obtained by Forbidden Stories and Amnesty Internatio­nal, and analysed by media organisati­ons around the world, including the Guardian. The numbers in the leaked records include those of Haya’s personal assistant, senior staff at her private security firm, and even one of the lawyers advising her in her custody dispute with Sheikh Mohammed.

NSO Group says it cannot see how its customers, which are all government­s, use its military-grade spyware Pegasus, which is capable of secretly infecting a mobile phone and then extracting massive amounts of data from it. It says Pegasus is only supposed to be used to prevent terrorism and serious crime, and that its clients sign contracts agreeing to these terms when they purchase a licence.

It believes the dataset examined by the media consortium has “no bearing on the list of the customers’ targets of Pegasus, or any other NSO products”, though it said

Haya says a helicopter landed at her house to ‘take a passenger to a desert prison’

it “may be part of a larger list of numbers that might have been used by NSO Group customers for other purposes” that were entirely legitimate.

NSO also says it is legally and contractua­lly prevented from identifyin­g its government clients. But a source familiar with the company’s operations confirmed that within the past year it had stripped Dubai of its Pegasus licence. The source said the decision had been informed primarily by human rights concerns, but did not dispute that the possibilit­y Sheikh Mohammed was wielding it against his own family had also been a factor.

Till Dunckel, a German lawyer representi­ng Sheikh Mohammed, told the newspaper Süddeutsch­e Zeitung: “Our client emphatical­ly denies having attempted to ‘hack’ the phones of the persons named in your request, or having instructed others to do so.” John Kelly, one of the sheikh’s British lawyers, echoed the same denials to the Guardian, but did not respond to any specific or detailed questions.

Much of what is known about the circumstan­ces in which Haya left Dubai for London is detailed in a fact-finding public judgment published by the high court last year. Her relationsh­ip with Sheikh Mohammed, which had been cordial, began to deteriorat­e following a highly public and unsuccessf­ul escape attempt by one of his children, Princess Latifa.

Haya, according to the judgment, began making inquiries about Latifa’s welfare, but began to experience a “progressiv­ely more hostile climate” from the sheikh and his advisers. Trusted staff members were dismissed without her approval, and Haya and her representa­tive were ejected from the ruler’s court – “a huge public slap in the face”, she said. She also discovered the sheikh had divorced her under sharia law on 7 February 2019, the anniversar­y of her father’s death, without telling her first.

A few weeks later, the judgment described how she claimed the sheikh had phoned her directly. “I have received bad news about you,” he said, making an ambiguous reference to her relationsh­ip with a bodyguard. “I am starting to doubt you.” Haya told the court that the call “terrified” her.

Anonymous, threatenin­g notes, and even firearms, were left in her bedroom, she claims. On 11 March 2019, a helicopter landed outside her house, and a pilot informed her that he had come to transport a single passenger to Awir, a desert prison in the UAE. Haya attempted to defuse the situation by laughing it off as a joke, while one of her children clung to her leg in terror, and the pilot eventually left. (Sheikh Mohammed told the court the incident was “simply a mistake”.)

Sheikh Mohammed, an amateur poet, also published verses online that appear to refer to Haya. In his February 2019 poem Luck Strikes Once, he wrote: “My spirit is cured of you, girl. When your face appears, no pleasure I feel. Don’t say troublemak­ers are the ones to blame. It’s your fault, though you’re fairer than the moon …”

Less ambiguous was You Lived, You Died, which he published in June 2019 and admits related to Haya. “You, traitor, you betrayed the most precious trust. I exposed you and your games …” he wrote. “I have the evidence that convicts you of what you have done … You know your actions are an insult … Let’s see if mischief brings you benefits, I care not whether you live or die.”

By this stage Haya had resolved that her position was “wholly unsafe and untenable”, and in April 2019 she arrived in England with her two children. She claims that the following month Sheikh Mohammed told her directly: “You and the children will never be safe in England.”

Shortly before Haya arrived in London, and continuing into at least the summer of 2019, the phone numbers of people around her began to appear on the database seen by the Pegasus project.

Among them were Martin Smith, the chief executive of Quest, which had for several years provided Haya with her private security. The firm’s director of investigat­ions was on the list, as was Shimon Cohen, a public relations expert and a communicat­ions adviser to Quest. John Gosden, a horse racing trainer and a friend of Haya, confirmed a number in the dataset belonged to him, but declined to comment.

Also appearing in the list were numbers belonging to one of Haya’s aides, and a lawyer at a London firm of solicitors advising her. The firm declined to comment, but asked the Pegasus project consortium not to identify the aide or the lawyer.

The investigat­ion by the Pegasus project suggests the presence of a number in the dataset reflects that the number was of interest to an NSO client, but it does not reveal whether any attempt to hack the phone was carried out. Haya declined to comment.

 ??  ?? Sheikh Mohammed
He divorced his wife under sharia law on the anniversar­y of her father’s death without telling her
Sheikh Mohammed He divorced his wife under sharia law on the anniversar­y of her father’s death without telling her
 ??  ?? Princess Haya
Her relationsh­ip with her husband began to deteriorat­e after she began inquiring about the welfare of Princess Latifa
Princess Haya Her relationsh­ip with her husband began to deteriorat­e after she began inquiring about the welfare of Princess Latifa
 ??  ?? ▲ Haya at the high court in 2019
▲ Haya at the high court in 2019

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom