Island campaigners in tunnel plea to end misery of trouble-hit ferry services
SCOTLAND’S northern isles are urgently pushing ministers for tunnels to cut the dependence on an ageing ferry fleet after it hit major financial difficulties in running services,
Vessels serving Shetland’s islands have an average age of 30 years and are said to be the number one cause of carbon emissions for the local authority.
Shetland is now planning to spend £400,000 to £600,000 to examine the future of transport on the islands – and the provision of toll tunnels at the cost of an estimated £400 million has been laid down as an option.
Orkney representatives have indicated that they are looking at bridges between islands to reduced the number of ferry services needed, because rock structures make tunnels unsuitable.
Shetland council and the regional transport partnership Zettrans have said that it wants a collaboration with ministers to pursue fixed links which would cut costs and help encourage people to stay on the islands and to grow the population.
In the current financial year, Shetland Islands Council received £17.5m that was ring-fenced for ferries, but said that it required £23.5m in the next financial year. In 2021/22 the ferry service ran at a £5.5m deficit having spent £22.9m.
But the council says that the extra money has not been made available by ministers leaving the service in a “critical condition”.
Moraig Lyall, chairman of Zettrans and the council’s environment and transport committee has criticised Transport Scotland for failing to be pro-active on the issue.
Shetland is an archipelago containing about 100 islands – 16 of which are inhabited. They include Yell, the second most northerly occupied island in the UK.
It is connected to the Shetland mainland by a three-mile ferry journey which usually takes about 20 minutes, but the ferries can be halted by severe weather or breakdowns.
A fleet of 12 ferries – with the oldest MV Hendra being 40-year-old – provides ferry services connecting mainland Shetland with outlying islands. Services run from 15 terminals on eight islands, providing a vital link for nearly 3,500 people.
Ferry services operate to Bressay, Fair Isle, Papa Stour, Foula, Whalsay, Skerries, Unst, Yell and Fetlar.
Now the council and Zettrans has warned that without the additional millions the local authority will be placed in an “unsustainable” position in funding inter-island ferry services.
They have said in an analysis: “It is no longer adequate to rely on a network of inter-island ferry services, even if the necessary revenue and capital investment can be secured [in a] long term basis
“The next generation of inter-island connectivity must be by way of fixed links rather than ferries where appropriate
“Fixed links have substantially lower operating costs relative to ferries and, although the initial capital investment is significant, they would deliver substantially greater value for money overall, with far lower financial uncertainty and risk, as well as a longterm reduction in carbon emissions.
“Fixed links would transform island economies and Shetland as a whole and would ensure a sustainable economic and social future for the archipelago was well as addressing the need to achieve net zero”.
The Faroe Islands, lying north west of Shetland, is made up of a series of 18 islets in the North Atlantic and has 21 tunnels – three of which are subsea.
Ms Lyall has told MSPS that the the standstill budget for ferries sees the council “staring down a hole in our finances that we don’t know how to fill” and with “difficult choices”.
She said the extra millions needed for running the ferry network was needed to pay for the rising cost of fuel, wages and maintenance.
She said communities were “passionate” about a move to tunnels.
The islands of Yell and Unst recently formed tunnel action groups because they were “pressing” to get this done.
A Transport Scotland spokesperson said: “Last year we published the second Strategic Transport Projects Review (STPR2), setting out 45 recommendations for future transport investment over the next 20 years.
“STPR2 did not consider the replacement of local ferry services by fixed links. This was out of scope, given it is a matter for the local authorities who manage and operate these.
“However we recognise the importance of these internal services to the Northern Isles and have provided local authorities with over £136m of investment in the last five years to support their operation.
“For this financial year more than £33m has been made available, including over £17m for Shetland Islands Council.”
Fixed links would transform island economies