The Herald - The Herald Magazine
End of the line for St Rollox?
THE SKILLED WORKERS FACING A LAST-DITCH BATTLE TO SAVE THEIR JOBS – AND THE LAST REMNANTS OF SCOTLAND’S ONCE-MIGHTY RAILWAY CAPITAL
THE late Tom Weir used to speak about his memories of growing up in Springburn, the railway capital of Scotland. His mother was a carriage-painter in the Cowlairs works of the North British Railways and he remembered her coming home with streaks of paint on her face and overalls.
As a milk boy of 12 he was often swept up in what he once described, in an STV interview, as the “avalanche of men that poured down Springburn Road every morning at half-past seven, answering the [factory] horns… If your hands were full of milk cans, you had to be off the street or be swept into Hyde Park works whether you liked it or not”.
Twenty-seven thousand people lived in Springburn when he was young, all of them engaged either in the building or servicing of locos, or working in the Co-op. Many thousands of locomotives were built at Springburn – at Cowlairs, at the Caledonian Railway works (the “Caley”), at the North British Locomotive Company’s works – over the decades.
As John Thomas puts it in his 1964 book The Springburn Story, “the good folk of Springburn were well used to the spectacle of out-of-gauge engines trundling down Springburn Road
in charge of a pair of snorting traction engines, bound for some sun-baked railway halfway round the world”.
Today, however, Springburn, has little left of that remarkable heritage, save the St Rollox works, which were opened in 1856.
Labour MP Hugh Gaffney’s grandfather Walter Freer worked there in the 1920s. “He lived in Springburn with his family and it was clear that St Rollox was the beating heart of the community,” Gaffney says. Once, when his wife became ill with multiple sclerosis, the management granted him a period of compassionate leave until the family could make arrangements to look after her.
“Many of those who worked at St Rollox also lived in Springburn, which fostered a great sense of community spirit,” Gaffney adds. “My grandfather loved his job and it enabled him to provide a good life for his family. He was a small man but with a big heart, and he always reserved a special place for St Rollox within it.”
Over the subsequent decades, St Rollox has shuttled from owner to owner: London, Midland and Scottish Railway, British Rail (latterly under its subsidiary British Rail Engineering Ltd); Babcock International/ Siemens, Alstom, RailCare, Knorr-Bremse, then Mutares, which owns Gemini Rail Services. But now it faces closure, and Springburn is in shock.
To quote from information placed before MSPs at Holyrood: “Mutares announced the closure of the works in December 2018.
In recent years, staff at the works have focused on rolling stock and component refurbishment.” At risk are some 180 jobs: a workforce of 120 plus around 60 agency staff. St Rollox specialises in handling older rolling stock. The Scottish Government has expressed disappointment that it only found out about the closure from the media.
A 45-day consultation was launched on January 17. The Unite union started a campaign, Rally Roon the Caley, demanding Network Rail carry out electrification to link St Rollox with the nearby Glasgow-Edinburgh rail line at an estimated cost of less than £1 million.
A spur from the flagship rail line would enable the depot to explore diversification, Unite believes.
It also wants the Scottish Government to bring the depot under its control “as an asset of strategic importance in Scotland’s transport infrastructure”.
The union says this demand is based on the precedent set by the Scottish Government when it brought Glasgow Prestwick Airport under its control in November 2013. As of Thursday morning, the campaign had attracted 2,293 signatures.
Gemini said last month that the consultation, which is scheduled to end on March 4, would permit the exploring of options with a view to avoiding redundancies.
A spokesman said: “The proposal [to
close] is as a result of increasingly changing and challenging market conditions which are outside of our control. It is very clear, as it has been for some time, that numbers of pre-privatisation rolling stock which have been the cornerstone of business for many years are in severe decline.
“Due to the introduction of more modern vehicles, the number of pre-privatisation vehicles in service will reduce by 80% in the next five years.
“Furthermore Springburn will continue to suffer an unsustainable decline in demand, due to its location, as only around 10% of the rolling stock that will be accessible is in Scotland and the north of England.
AS such, it is necessary to put forward the proposal. The decision to make this proposal has not been made lightly.”
To Bob Doris, the SNP MSP for Maryhill and Springburn, the potential closure is a “devastating” blow for the workforce, local communities and the locomotive industry. To the Rail, Maritime and Transport union it is “an act of industrial vandalism that will not go unchallenged”.
Glasgow Labour MSP James Kelly, who hosted a debate on St Rollox at Holyrood in midweek, believes government intervention is needed to save the jobs and the plant.
Gaffney says: “It would do a disservice to the proud history of generations of St Rollox workers for it to be closed, and would strike a blow to the community of Springburn.”
Pat McIlvogue, Unite’s regional industrial officer at Unite, who is responsible for the works, says the union campaign has attracted “huge” support not just from across Scotland but also from South Africa and Canada.
“The uniqueness of St Rollox is that it has history and heritage all around the world,” he says. “It has been a cornerstone of engineering here for 150 years. The depot is highly skilled and efficient. It’s the biggest depot for rail maintenance in Scotland.
“Mutares has told us privately that it wishes it could take the Springburn depot and replant it in England, because they have decided that they don’t want it to be in Scotland.
“But the skills, the knowledge, experience, the quality of workmanship and the affinity that people have with the site are all way above the average.”
The union believes that with “a bit of forward thinking” there could be a long-term future for Springburn. It urged Gemini not to impose the 45-day statutory notice but instead to work to find a way for “key stakeholders” to put together a feasible rescue plan.
The union queries the £1 million loss that Gemini says it has made at Springburn and Mr McIlvogue said in a Facebook video post: “We believe that with true management that that loss can … be turned around.”
He says the depot has enough work on diesel rolling stock to keep it open in the short to medium term; electrification would give it access to two-thirds of the Scottish rail stock and thus prolong its lifespan.
Paul Sweeney, Labour MP for Glasgow
Mutares has told us privately that it wishes it could take the Springburn depot and replant it in England
North East and a Shadow Scotland Office Minister, was quick to involve himself in the crisis, meeting a director of Gemini Rail Services.
His mother’s uncle Jimmy was an employee at St Rollox in the 1960s and 1970s. “She used to tell me about him working there as a wee boy,” he says.
That’s the thing about St Rollox, he adds. “Even though there are only 200 people working there now, there are thousands of people, still alive, who’re associated with the place.
“That’s why it has maybe punched above its weight for a normal factory with 200 workers. It has a bigger hinterland, a bigger community around it.”
THAT community has suffered, though. Over the years, the decline of Springburn and the loss of some of its fine old buildings have prompted much anguish.
“Historic Springburn was literally sliced in half in the 1960s by wholesale demolition of good tenement buildings for the construction of the A803 road,” writes Ian Mitchell in his updated book Glasgow’s Industrial Past.
The road damaged Springburn, Mitchell says, even though it was not built for its inhabitants. It forcibly divided one half of Springburn from its shops and facilities. Similarly there’s little physical evidence of the once-mighty presence of the area’s rail works.
“The St Rollox site once took in the whole area that is now the Royal Mail Sorting Office, Costco and the Tesco,” says Sweeney.
“It has been downsized quite substantially since the 1980s. At one time, at its peak, there were 15,000 people involved in the locomotive industry in Springburn. It was a huge industrial concern, just as shipbuilding was.
“People think that the Finnieston Crane [near the SEC] was built to serve the shipbuilding industry but in actual fact the bulk of its work was lifting the big steam locomotives onto ships.”
In a speech that began not long before 2am on January 14, Sweeney told the Commons that the Caley works had existed since the dawn of the railway age and that, during the Second World War, it turned out Airspeed Horsa gliders for the Normandy landing airborne assault of D-Day in June 1944. “It is very sad that we could be witnessing the end of an industry that is synonymous with the community of Springburn in which it was built.”
In his view now, St Rollox has in recent years “gone through a succession of private owners. It has always been in a bit of a precarious situation; it has been passed from various different owners.
“What has happened is symptomatic of some other Glasgow industries. They become branch plants, so that the ownership and the management decision-making is no longer in the city. The entrepreneurial drivers aren’t in the city any more, so they’re basically at the mercy of decisions that are made in boardrooms far away from Glasgow.
“That’s the key problem with what’s happened at Springburn. The main headquarters of what’s known as Gemini – until a few months ago, Knorr-Bremse – is at Wolverton railway works in Milton Keynes. The vast majority of the staff, all of the decision-makers, all of the white-collar staff, are all based there. And even though that site is underperforming relative to Springburn, they still decided to shut Springburn and concentrate their operations at Milton Keynes.
“So our view is, this is not just a fight to save the heritage of locomotive engineering in Springburn. It’s also about trying to re-establish an entrepreneurial spirit for the locomotive industry in Glasgow.
“The Reid family were the big entrepreneurs behind the North British Locomotive Company [it was created in 1903 through the merger of three locomotive manufacturers and became a industrial colossus].
“If you look at their huge headquarters building on Flemington Street in Springburn, you can think of the wealth and the ambition that were once there in Springburn, a century ago. To think it has now been whittled to its last gasp is quite sad. Part of the problem is not just the issue about keeping the works open – it’s actually, ‘Let’s create a platform from which we can grow the industry again’.
“There’s huge potential for engineering. Look at Allied Vehicles in Possilpark – it has grown from nothing to having 500-odd employees. That’s because there’s been local entrepreneurialism, local management, local decision-making leading it. My feeling is that, with the right sort of restructuring, St Rollox can have that sort of prosperous growth ahead of it.”
Daryl Steel, 44, a maintenance fitter-electrician, has worked at Caley for 28 years. He followed in the footsteps of his father and his grandfather. His dad was a production manager years ago, in charge of around 1,000 people. “Quite a lot of us older guys have had family members who worked at the yard,” is how he puts it.
“The skills base that will be lost if the depot closes will be incredible. You will never be able to replace it. I feel Springburn is being shafted to preserve the English workforce [at Wolverton]. The English depot is a shambles and it’s responsible for 90 per cent of the losses that the company is making.
“Since the yard was privatised, no company has run it for more than five years,” Steel adds. “What we’re hoping for is the Scottish Government to intervene, because otherwise the majority of ScotRail’s older fleet would need to be repaired in England.
“All you’re talking about is a mile of overhead electric line to put us onto the main Glasgow-Edinburgh line,” he adds. “The amount of work that that could bring in … It could be another shed that ScotRail could use for storing its vehicles and doing overnight examinations in addition to the existing Eastfield depot. The guys in our place, although they’re traditionally doing heavy maintenance and overhaul, could quite easily adapt to any other kind of railway work.”
Derek Hearton, 53, who is in his 37th year at St Rollox, says: “I think the writing’s been on the wall for a few years. Between us and Wolverton, Wolverton has been making huge losses. Obviously we were in administration five years ago. I thought when the German company came in they would have turned it around, but they didn’t do what they said they were going to do.
“It’s unfortunate what has happened to St Rollox, because it’s a good site and it’s a great place to work. But now we think there’s no chance. But that’s the thing – we’re still putting the jobs out on time, we’re still doing really well, and they guys are still all working to the end. They haven’t given up.”
Last week Transport Secretary Michael Matheson, who chairs a stakeholder group which aims to save St Rollox, said Network Rail had expressed an interest that it could be involved in the future under a multi-agency railway hub model based at St Rollox. “A hub idea could include the public and private sector,” he said.
“We are not going to give up on the site. We will do all we can. But that will take time. That’s why we are applying pressure on the owners.”