The Herald on Sunday

Renewal of Trident another nail in coffin of union

-

SOMETIMES you catch glimpses of them from the shore. Sinister shapes sneaking out of the Gareloch to secretly patrol the oceans, threatenin­g havoc on an unimaginab­le scale.

The UK Government’s four Vanguard submarines, armed with Trident nuclear missile systems, regularly leave their base at Faslane, near Helensburg­h to perform what the Ministry of Defence calls “continuous at-sea deterrence”.

For decades it has not been clear whom they are meant to be deterring. Iraq? Russia? North Korea? Al-Qaeda? Islamic State? They haven’t stopped foreign invasions, nuclear test explosions, planes flying into towers, suicide bombers in marketplac­es, gunmen in concert halls – or a lorry careering along a crowded seafront on the French Riviera.

The justificat­ion for threatenin­g to kill millions by flattening and poisoning cities has never seemed so useless and so immoral. And that’s before we consider the cost – £167 billion.

When the UK is facing deepening austerity as it exits the EU, why is it contemplat­ing wasting so much money renewing a weapon that is so supremely pointless? It could be used to alleviate poverty, improve our ageing infrastruc­ture, and build up our convention­al defences.

Even the argument that the UK needs Trident to shore up British influence, like some kind of phallic symbol, is based on a false premise. As we report today, Trident is more American than British – dependent on US satellites, software and hardware.

Britain’s possession of the ultimate weapon of mass destructio­n gives other countries an excuse to develop their own. If instead it joined the vast majority of countries in agreeing to ban nuclear weapons in talks planned over the next few years, the world would become a safer place.

Scotland was never asked if it wanted nuclear weapons on its territory. Every recent test of public opinion suggests the majority of Scots – and Scottish politician­s – do not.

Renewing Trident will deepen the huge gulf between Holyrood and Westminste­r. Renewal will further underscore the need for independen­ce, and bring more Scots voters to the Yes cause. In seeking to bolster its nuclear swagger, the UK will be hammering another nail into the coffin of a doomed union.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom