Scottish Government facing £5m bill after losing High Court case over shipyard takeover
THE Scottish Government could be left with a £5 million bill to an insurance company after losing a High Court case related to its takeover of the Ferguson Marine ferries shipyard.
Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited (CMAL), the Government-owned company which commissioned the ferries, sought to rectify an agreement with HCC International Insurance Company.
The Texas-based insurance company says it is owed the multi-million windfall as a result of the way the Government bought the troubled shipyard when it was in administration during 2019.
The shipyard is constructing two ferries which were originally meant to enter service in 2018 but are still unfinished, with costs spiralling.
On Friday, a decision from deputy High Court Judge Simon Gleeson was published.
His ruling came after the
Government lost another case against HCC International Insurance Company at the Court of Session in May last year. Judge Gleeson said: “It is easy to see why this decision seems to have caused so much anger and irritation among Scottish ministers.
“In paying for the business of FMEL (Ferguson Marine) by reducing FMEL’s liabilities to them, they believed that they were simply transferring their own money from one pocket to another, with the transaction having no impact on their overall obligations.”
He added: “The discovery that the choice of transaction structure had resulted in their being required to pay a little over £5m to a third party must have been highly unwelcome.”
Scottish ministers, through CMAL, sought to rectify a commercial agreement known as a deed of settlement with HCC. However, Judge Gleeson refused this and granted a summary judgment in favour of HCC.
He noted: “As a result of a series of subsequent developments, the terms of this deed produced an outcome which came as a surprise to all those involved in its negotiation, producing a significant windfall gain for one party at the expense of the owner of the other.”
The judge also noted that CMAL was wholly owned by Scottish ministers at all relevant times.
A Scottish Government spokesman said: “We are aware of a summary judgment that has been made in the English courts in relation to the claim brought by CMAL against HCCI.”
The first of the Ferguson Marine ferries, the Glen Sannox, is currently expected to be ready some time between July and September 2022. The second is not due for completion until April to July 2023.