The Independent

As a 15-year-old British Muslim girl, I know how Shamima Begum was misled

-

I am a 15-year-old British Muslim girl around the same age of Shamima Begum when she joined Isis. Whilst I could never contemplat­e doing what she did, I can understand how people can be easily influenced and groomed these days through technology and organisati­ons such as Isis – who have nothing to do with Islam.

Grooming is grooming whether it is far-right organisati­ons or other extremist organisati­ons.

I do not agree with what Begum did and could never do that myself, especially as I believe Islam is a religion of peace which promotes tolerance and respect for all. As a British Muslim I am lucky that I can practice my religion freely in the UK, and I believe there is no contradict­ion between British and Muslim values.

However, youngsters face a lot of challenges these days and if they do not feel wanted or a sense of belonging they can easily be misled. Being confident in who you are, your beliefs and having good role models helps. If this support structure is not there then you can easily go down the wrong track.

Should Begum be allowed to return to the UK? This stirs up different emotions and responses from people. As a young teenager of a similar age, I think our response has to be a considered and measured one.

Of course what she did was wrong, but if she was groomed or radicalise­d, then is she at fault? On the other hand we need to make sure she does not pose a risk to the security of our country. Whatever the wrongs or rights, her child is innocent.

This issue, while it may seem to some as straightfo­rward, is a complex one. I think we should show some compassion for the sake of her child.

I think we should take the moral high ground and not act in the same way as these extremists. This may even have a positive effect and bode well for the future.

As for Begum, it is only right that if she returns, she is investigat­ed and if any crime has been committed she should be charged and sentenced accordingl­y. Given what she has done, she should be monitored carefully and have strict restrictio­ns so that she can not cause harm to our country or any individual.

Fateha Aftab Address supplied

Why doesn’t anyone care about the grooming?

I recall clearly the reports of three schoolgirl­s from Bethnal Green Academy going off to Syria to “marry”

(be sexually abused by) men they’d met online. Now we hear that at least one of them is still alive, albeit in a refugee camp.

Politician­s waited a couple of days to take the temperatur­e of public opinion and listen to Twitter twaddle and the gutter press and now are taking a stance. We no longer, of course, expect something we used to call leadership.

As a mother of three daughters (now a granny) I can only say I am aghast at the idea that a teenager, who was groomed and sexually and mentally exploited at an age when most girls are screaming at their parents because they aren’t allowed to stay out past 11pm, should be further abused by her own government.

Get her home now, take responsibi­lity for this home-grown problem and start doing something useful like finding out HOW and WHY this happened.

Amanda Baker Edinburgh

Bangladesh shouldn’t have to take Begum

If someone called Jane Smith, born in the UK to two British parents, were to join a terrorist organisati­on as a non-combatant, would it be acceptable for the government to take away her British nationalit­y on the grounds that one of her parents/grandparen­ts was born in Italy, making her eligible for Italian nationalit­y?

And what would Italy have to say about being sent a British subject who the British government considered to be a criminal, despite them never having been there before?

I think we know the answer, so why should Bangladesh act any differentl­y? What is the Conservati­ve government trying to achieve? Could it be to appeal to the hard right?

John Simpson Ross on Wye

Brit awards for Brits only

I completely agree with David Lister’s piece about giving a Brit Award to Pink (Section 2, yesterday). I’m not even sure who she is or if I would recognise any of her music – and I often listen to BBC 6 Music.

It is truly ridiculous and somewhat insulting that she (I just realised I had assumed her gender from the name/colour reference) is singled out for this award when so many others that Lister lists are passed over.

But anyway, I don’t care too much as I won’t be watching the show. Peter Cole Alnwick

Tom Watson’s amnesia

I was interested in Tom Watson’s comments about Jeremy Corbyn including a wider range of views in his appointmen­ts to his front bench.

Surely that’s what he did as soon as he became leader? Some point blank refused to serve, and others staged that mass walkout. Has Watson forgotten all that?

M Hutchins Christchur­ch

What’s keeping the other Labour MPs from leaving?

I wholeheart­edly back the Independen­t Group splitters. Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour is a pro-Brexit, antisemiti­c party that allies itself with the world’s worst tyrants.

Luciana Berger, Chuka Umunna and the other six MPs are courageous heroes for standing up against the bigotry and bullying of the militant hard left.

I resent Corbyn and his shambolic “leadership” of a once great party; sadly, though, he and his fellow cronies have taken over Labour.

All decent Labour MPs should therefore look long and hard in the mirror, and decide whether they can, hand on heart, remain in a repugnantl­y racist political party.

Sebastian Monblat Address supplied

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom