The Independent

My hormonal wake-up call

The menopause is almost a rite of passage for women, writes Charlotte Cripps, so why did I never think it would affect me? Now I have learnt I am perimenopa­usal and need HRT


Mention the word menopause – or perimenopa­use for that matter – and I always used to yawn. I had no hot flushes. No night sweats. No brain fog. It wasn’t happening to me. In fact, I was so certain I wasn’t suffering from it that I dropped my copy of Davina McCall’s new book, Menopausin­g: The Positive

Roadmap to Your Second Spring, off at the local charity shop for someone who might need it.

Of course, I’d heard about the symptoms women go through. Yes, the hot flushes and night sweats, but also loss of confidence, hair falling out, crawling skin, brittle nails, vaginal dryness, incontinen­ce, and burning tongue. These are symptoms that have led 1 in 10 women to leave their job in the UK, according to a new survey.

I’d also seen the news. In 2002, hormone replacemen­t therapy (HRT) got a bad rap thanks to a study that warned of the increased risk of breast cancer and therefore many women stopped taking the treatment. It took about 10 years for the data to be re-analysed to find major flaws in the study.

Recently, there has also been a nationwide shortage of HRT on the NHS, leaving women desperate. McCall recently told the BBC’s Sunday Morning show that if there was a shortage of insulin or any other drug it would “get sorted out immediatel­y”. Plus, with the cost of living crisis, campaigner­s like Holly Willoughby are up in arms that women should have to pay for HRT prescripti­ons on the NHS – it’s nearly £10 per item for three months supply.

But is HRT for everybody? What exactly is it and is it safe? Menopause is like a rite of passage for women. So why have I never cared?

Then I started waking up at 3am. With little sleep and two small kids and a job, I started to panic. I had no history of insomnia, even at times when I had far more going on than I do now. It had been going on for a week when a friend said “get your hormones checked out”. My hormones?

The average age of menopause in the UK is about 51 and is defined as the absence of menstruati­on for 12 months. But the period of hormonal fluctuatio­n leading up to this is called the perimenopa­use and can last many years.

It hadn’t crossed my mind that at just over 45 I was going through the perimenopa­use or, God forbid, the menopause. I rang my GP sobbing. It’s true my periods had become erratic after I stopped breastfeed­ing in late 2019 but, with no other symptoms of perimenopa­use, I’d put that down to my body being confused after years of gruelling IVF.

I got an emergency GP appointmen­t, but because I am over 45, I was not entitled to a blood test to measure my hormone levels. It’s normal practice to be prescribed standardis­ed HRT by a good GP as soon as you start to experience menopausal symptoms and, as I hadn’t had a period for over 12 months, any investigat­ion was deemed unnecessar­y.

The doctor prescribed an Oestrogel pump pack gel to be rubbed into my thigh once daily and a 100mg oral capsule of progestero­ne at night – it all felt somewhat random.

Nightol was also suggested to help me sleep. She also ordered blood tests that the NHS would allow – kidney function, cholestero­l, iron levels, and one basic thyroid function test. I was in and out of the GP surgery in five minutes.

After talking to friends, I found many of them were on bioidentic­al hormones, which come from plant sterols but have the same chemical structure as our own natural hormones and so are well tolerated by the body. They were bandying words like “safer” and made of “yam and plant extracts”.

Others told me bioidentic­al hormones were a bit witchy woo. You could also get them online but could you guarantee the quality?

What was the difference between the two types of HRTs, synthetic and bioidentic­al? I decided to find out. It seemed advisable to at least get my hormone levels checked out. I didn’t pick up my NHS prescripti­on and googled bioidentic­al hormones, it seemed Angelina Jolie and Oprah Winfrey were advocating them.

She has a particular interest in the impact of trauma on hormone health, especially the adrenal glands. Adrenal dysregulat­ion or the pattern of cortisol, our stress hormone, drives many imbalances

I headed to the Marion Gluck Clinic which is the UK’s leading hormone-balancing clinic that pioneered bioidentic­al hormones in the UK 25 years ago. They also treat male menopause or andropause with TRT (testostero­ne replacemen­t therapy) for symptoms including low libido and fatigue.

It started with an initial Zoom consultati­on with Dr Ghazala Aziz-Scott – the “queen” of bioidentic­al hormones and the clinical lead doctor. She is an Oxbridge-trained neuroscien­tist

and medical doctor who was a former NHS GP for 25 years and has been entrusted by the founder, Dr Marion Gluck, with continuing the pioneering work of the clinic with a team of nine other very experience­d doctors.

She and her team take a holistic approach to treating patients. The session lasts 45 minutes and costs £320. She asks me about my medical history and symptoms but also for my life story. She then sends me off for a full panel of blood tests costing £305.

Seven vials of blood are taken from my arm and soon I have the results back for 67 tests. I also do the Nordic Dutch Plus test costing £319 to check for adrenal dysregulat­ion and evaluate how my body metabolise­s hormones, particular­ly oestrogen. This will, according to Dr Ghazala, assess if I produce more toxic oestrogen metabolite­s which could increase breast cancer risk and affect my long-term safety of taking HRT – should I need it. I do the test at home over a day (saliva and urine samples) and it’s sent to the US to fine-tune the next level of treatment.

First, I learn that I have hypothyroi­dism – an underactiv­e thyroid. Common signs of an underactiv­e thyroid include tiredness, weight gain, and depression. I’m prescribed daily hormone replacemen­t tablets, Levothyrox­ine 25mg, to raise thyroxine levels that my thyroid gland isn’t producing enough of. And with a hypothyroi­dism diagnosis, Dr Ghazala informed

me that I can now get all my prescripti­ons free on the NHS for life.

Usually, the NHS only measure Thyroid Stimulatin­g Hormone (TSH) – as in my case – and if it’s abnormal they measure T4. Mine that day was within the normal NHS range at 3.97, but “the TSH can fluctuate depending on the time of day,” says Dr Ghazala. My TSH in the private blood test one week later is 5.39, which is too high.

“We also need to look at the T4 (thyroxine)and T3 (triiodothy­ronine) to get an overall picture of thyroid function,” says Dr Ghazala. “We tend to like the TSH below two which indicates an optimal balance, but NHS ranges have higher margins.”

She also picks up on the high cholestero­l as did my GP, but it’s all adding up now. An underactiv­e thyroid can affect cholestero­l metabolism so, once my thyroid is sorted, it may normalise. I am emailed food plans from the Institute of Functional Medicine that will guide me to improve my metabolic health.

On to my hormones. Well, yes, I’m perimenopa­usal. My progestero­ne levels are very low – this is the soothing and calming hormone so it explains my irritabili­ty, anxiety and sleeplessn­ess. I also have fluctuatin­g oestrogen, a lack of which can cause hot flushes, and general aches and pains. Oestrogen also affects collagen production affecting the quality of skin and hair.

By Saturday I feel lighter. Not only mentally clearer and sharper, but lighter in body weight as if I’m deflating. All the water retention is easing away

My DHEA (Dehydroepi­androstero­ne) is very good at 9.2 – usually, she’s looking at levels of about 3. She thinks this high DHEA is why I’ve had no perimenopa­usal symptoms until now as DHEA is a precursor to the sex hormones and acts as a reservoir. My testostero­ne is also at a good level.

Dr Ghazala prescribes me transderma­l oestrogen and progestero­ne creams before our next appointmen­t eight weeks later, when she will retest my blood results and we will have the Nordic Test back. Then my personalis­ed hormones will all be combined into one single pump of cream for easy usage; it’s like a pea-sized amount of cream that is easily absorbed in the skin unlike the far larger lump of clear oestrogen gel I would have been rubbing into my thigh on the NHS and with an oral progestero­ne.

But what exactly is the difference between bioidentic­al hormones and HRT on the NHS? It turns out – not much. While some women are still being prescribed synthetic HRT on the NHS, the NHS has largely switched to body identical hormones, which my GP prescribed me. It is also plant-based like bioidentic­al hormones. The big difference is I’m getting a bespoke service. If you have the funds, it’s a wonderful way to monitor your ever-changing hormone levels and take the HRT tailor-made for you, rather than a one size fits all.

The next step is exciting and I wonder when I will feel better. I’m told it can be as quick as 24 to 48 hours. One of Dr Ghazala’s patients described it like “the Christmas tree lights coming on”.

“I feel like I’ve poured a watering can on my patients – like they’ve bloomed,” says Dr Ghazala about meeting patients once the meds kick in at the eight-week appointmen­t.

My medication arrives special delivery by Royal Mail – no need to visit a pharmacy this way. It’s a Thursday and I take the first pill Levothyrox­ine for hypothyroi­dism. I reach for my “customised hormone creams” next. Progestero­ne – I push one pump onto my lower arm and rub it in with the other lower forearm. Then onto the estradiol – one pump daily for one week then going up to twice daily until she combines them into one pump when she’s checked I’m on the right amount.

By Saturday I feel lighter. Not only mentally clearer and sharper, but lighter in body weight as if I’m deflating. All the water retention is easing away and I’m sleeping better. According to Dr Ghazala this is due to the extra progestero­ne I’m getting which helps with fluid retention. She also suggested I get a magnesium supplement to help with sleep and calm the nervous system.

It’s interestin­g that compounded bioidentic­al HRT – such as the treatment I’m given at the Marion Gluck Clinic – is unlicensed.

Why is this the case if they are the same as body identical HRT from the NHS?

While the British Menopause Society has advised medics to consider alternativ­e HRT preparatio­ns for women who cannot get their usual stock of Oestrogel during the shortage of HRT, including the gel Sandrena or the spray Lenzetto – they still don’t advocate the use of “compounded bioidentic­al hormones”. I asked the British Menopause Society (BMS) about it.

They sent me a report explaining why they do not licence compounded Bioidentic­al hormones; reasons include they don’t carry warning leaflets and are commercial­ly available in a regulated form, so compoundin­g is not justified. But, according to Ghazala, it’s more about cost and she says all the products from Marion Gluck’s specialist pharmacy do have warning leaflets.

“The individual components oestrogen, progestero­ne and testostero­ne are licenced in bioidentic­al hormones but as the compounded bioidentic­al HRT is tailor-made for each patient, it is classified as unlicenced,” she says.

“As they are natural products with limited scope for a patent, there is no incentive for big pharmaceut­ical companies to fund large-scale randomised controlled clinical trials to assess this, as unpatented products have limited scope for profit.”

Only big pharmaceut­ical companies can afford the astronomic­al costs of licencing a medication. “The NHS is population-based medicine,” she adds. “It needs to be cost-effective, guideline-driven and act for the greater good – individual­ised compoundin­g is expensive.”

What is my conclusion? The good news is that my GP did actually prescribe me the correct HRT. It was plant-based and bioidentic­al, although Dr Ghazala is starting me off on a third of that dose and working me up to the higher dose. But it can often feel like luck of the draw on the NHS.

“If you are oestrogen dominant and aren’t properly assessed as you are over 45, you would have felt worse on HRT containing extra oestrogen and might have decided HRT wasn’t for you.”

Some GPs are still prescribin­g synthetic oral HRT on the NHS, “We know that oestrogen should be given transderma­lly to decrease the risk of thromboemb­olic events or clots, but they are still being given oral oestrogen preparatio­ns, and some of the combined HRT patches used have synthetic progestins in them which are more linked to breast cancer risk,” says Dr Ghazala.

The cost privately could become expensive as hormone levels are checked regularly for three to six months and correlated with symptoms to optimise the dose and check it is working – a follow-up is £160. Annual blood tests are needed thereafter – costing £200 to £250. The beauty of bioidentic­al HRT is that “we can adjust the levels of hormones and type of formulatio­n to suit the individual” says Dr Ghazala because treatment is personalis­ed and compounded in our specialist pharmacy.

For some women, places like the Marion Gluck Clinic are a last resort. A report called Menopause and The Workplace, by the gender equality charity, the Fawcett Society, found that only 39 per cent of women who spoke to someone at their GP practice said they were offered HRT once they were diagnosed with menopause.

“Our compounded products are always available, and we have no supply issues. NHS supply issues created a lot of stress for women, and they often had to change brands which can then have variable absorption, and this can affect symptom control. Sometimes women were then put onto the synthetic oral preparatio­ns.”

Private menopause treatment might not be affordable for everybody. Until the 8-week appointmen­t, it cost £1,104, minus

the private prescripti­on charges – it’s £100 for the compounded hormone cream approximat­ely every three months (160 pumps lasts 80 days if you are doing two pumps a day). If a new hormone is added it’s £10 per hormone. The bases can be hypoallerg­enic and if you don’t tolerate taking it transderma­lly, it can be made into sublingual lozenges or even vegan drops to be used under the tongue. You will see the same hormone doctor who is available for ongoing assessment and provides continuity of care. A prescribin­g nurse is also on hand for emergency repeat prescripti­ons.

They also prescribe regulated body identical hormones costing a £10 prescripti­on charge but with the advantage of in-depth monitoring. Additional hormones such as compounded testostero­ne and DHEA that is not available on the NHS can be added. “It’s a win-win,” says Dr Ghazala.

If money wasn’t an issue, I’d definitely stick with Dr Ghazala as the monitoring is so reassuring and it is combining the HRT into one bespoke cream. But – now I get free NHS prescripti­ons due to my hypothyroi­dism – I’m tempted to convert my meds into body identical hormones and take the oral progestero­ne, which she says is safe.

Do I feel better? Yes, I’m sleeping and I’ve lost weight. My heart feels open again. I’m not in a state of rage and insomnia. I might not feel the full benefits yet but I feel like a whole new world has

opened up for me. Thankfully I won’t one day be having a hot flush or worse as I’ve got the hormones right next to me in a single pump of high-quality cream.

Synthetic HRT was promoted as the “fountain of youth” in the 1980s, but it is now largely a thing of the past. Since 2019, Body identical HRT is deemed the gold standard by the BMS, not synthetic HRT. While some women sail through the menopause, many don’t. I seem to have caught it just before it could have become worse.

“As long as it’s bioidentic­al or body identical HRT being used, women can be on treatment long term,” says Dr Ghazala. “It helps with short-term symptoms of perimenopa­use and menopause, but also has longer-term benefits for health such as osteoporos­is prevention, cardiovasc­ular disease and prevention of degenerati­ve brain conditions such as Alzheimer’s. A woman born today can live until she’s 100 so we have to ensure a good healthspan as well as a good lifespan.”

An initial consultati­on at The Marion Gluck Clinic costs £320

Want your views to be included in The Independen­t Daily Edition letters page? Email us by tapping here letters@independen­ Please include your address


 ?? (Getty) ?? Waking up in the midd l e of the night is a common symptom of the menopause
(Getty) Waking up in the midd l e of the night is a common symptom of the menopause
 ?? (The Marion G uck C inic) ?? The Marion G l uck c l inic carries out extensive tests to work out exact l y what you need
(The Marion G uck C inic) The Marion G l uck c l inic carries out extensive tests to work out exact l y what you need
 ?? (The Marion Guck Cinic) ?? Using a custom hormone p l an, some of the worst symptoms can be overcome
(The Marion Guck Cinic) Using a custom hormone p l an, some of the worst symptoms can be overcome
 ?? (Marion Guck Clinic) ?? Compounded bioidentic­a l HRT is tai l or- made for each patient
(Marion Guck Clinic) Compounded bioidentic­a l HRT is tai l or- made for each patient
 ?? (Rodney Pedroza) ?? Dr Ghazala Aziz - Scott takes a ho l istic approach to treating patients
(Rodney Pedroza) Dr Ghazala Aziz - Scott takes a ho l istic approach to treating patients
 ?? ?? Celebritie­s such as Davina McCall are campaignin­g against HRT prescripti­on charges (PA)
Celebritie­s such as Davina McCall are campaignin­g against HRT prescripti­on charges (PA)

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom