Minister admits ambulance delays risk needless deaths
There is a “material risk” that patients are dying unnecessarily because of long ambulance delays, the health secretary has admitted. But Steve Barclay also signalled that there are plans to scale back the number of NHS targets, seen as a key measure of NHS performance. And he faced accusations that he was peddling “frankly pretty dishonest stuff” as he defended the
government’s actions on the health service in the face of criticism from the leader of one of the country’s largest unions.
Pressed on the BBC’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg programme on the question of whether people are dying because of ambulance delays, Mr Barclay conceded: “If there is a delay in an ambulance getting to someone, in terms of unmet need, then obviously that is a material risk.”
He insisted that improvements were being made to the “flow” of patients, following stories of long waiting times and ambulances being stuck for hours outside hospitals. But the government has been criticised for an announcement last week that long-delayed social care reforms will be put off for another two years.
Matthew Taylor, the chief executive of the NHS Confederation, which represents managers of hospital trusts, told Sky News that “almost every hospital” in England, Wales and Northern Ireland “has got wards full of people who could go home, who should go home”, but that there are not enough social care staff to look after them. He added that the health service has problems with “how we recruit, how we retain and how we motivate our staff”.
As the row raged, health minister Will Quince said he was “to blame” for unnecessary deaths in the NHS. “Ultimately, I’m the minister, I am to blame. And it’s my responsibility. It’s my
responsibility to fix this,” he told Times Radio. “Anybody who dies prematurely or needlessly whilst waiting for an ambulance, I take incredibly seriously, and my heart goes out to them, and indeed their families.” He said that 90 per cent of the issues around discharging patients are occurring across only half of NHS trusts.
Gary Smith, the general secretary of the GMB union, said Mr Barclay was “deluded” in regard to government funding for the NHS and care services. “Why didn’t they tax non-doms? Why didn’t they tax the richest people in this country, with the broadest shoulders, who pay no tax at all? What have they done about bankers’ bonuses?” he asked.
“The Tory government has made ideological decisions for over a decade about cutting services, and that’s what has left services on their knees, and this is not hyperbole – our care homes were turned into morgues during the pandemic because of mismanagement and cuts. People are dying because of cuts to services, so I find that interview utterly dishonest, and frankly the minister is deluded.”
Last month, an interview with the health secretary was interrupted by a woman who accused him of “doing nothing” about ambulance response times. The latest NHS figures show an average wait of more than an hour for heart attack and stroke victims last month. Documents published alongside last week’s autumn statement commit the NHS to improving some performance targets, including halving average ambulance response times for this category of patient.
Want your views to be included in The Independent Daily Edition letters page? Email us by tapping here letters@independent.co.uk. Please include your address