The Jewish Chronicle

Larry David — the Gants Hill version

-

BBC Two

BBC One

GR A NDMA’S HOUSE is, in the great BBC tradition, a sitcom about family life in the suburbs — but T e r r y a n d J u n e i t ain’t. As the continuity announcer might say, this programme contains strong language from the outset and explicit references to gay sex, drugs and, er, bridge rolls.

For those of you who missed the first series, it is a comedy in the Larry David tradition, set in Gants Hill, in which comedian Simon Amstell plays a version of himself and actors play a version of his family. The Amstell character is constantly in fear of embarrassm­ent by his, frankly, very embarrassi­ng family. His discomfort when he wakes up in bed with a 16-year-old boy who turns out to be the disturbed classmate of his cousin Adam, is excruciati­ng, but also hilarious (if you happen to be a very broad-minded un-homophobic adult).

There is something very Jewishly authentic in the unabashed discussion of Simon’s (much regretted) night of passion with a schoolboy, particular­ly as it occurs in a family which seems much more preoccupie­d with the broiges between Simon’s mum and aunt (played respective­ly by Rebecca Front and Samantha Spiro) which has simmered for months over the catering for their father’s funeral.

And this being (a version of) the Jewish community, the rebellious, drugtaking boy who wakes up in Simon’s bed turns out to be Mark Grossman, whose grandma plays kalooki with Simon’s grandma.

As a viewer who has endured years of depressing domesticit­y masqueradi­ng as TV comedy, Grandma’s House is sharp, refreshing and yet comforting­ly Jewish. Grandma, following the destructio­n of the armchair formerly occupied by the dear, departed Bernie, says: “There are worse things in life than a broken chair. Some people have no legs.” There is a lesson for all of us there.

Witness to Auschwitz examined the story of Denis Avey, a British prisoner of war, whose book, The Man Who Broke Into Auschwitz, has caused huge controvers­y. There is no doubt that Avey was at the death camp. Indeed Ernst Lobethall, an inmate there, has testified that Avey saved his life by smuggling cigarettes to him which he was able to use as currency. However, the central claim of Avey’s book — that he swapped places with another inmate, Hans, so he could investigat­e conditions in Auschwitz — is hotly disputed.

Avey wrote that he entered the camp in disguise twice and his account of a night among the “stripeys”, as he called them, is harrowing. However, there are allegation­s of discrepanc­ies between the book and Avey’s 2001 Imperial War Museum interview. There are also questions over why he kept his silence for more than 50 years. Even fellow POW Brian Bishop said that such a swap would have been “unfeasible”.

But Avey, a robust nonagenari­an, appeared unaffected by the row. “I know what happened and that is all that matters to me,” he said.

His account was backed by historian Lyn Smith who conducted that first interview with Avey. She said it was unsurprisi­ng that in attempting to recall events for the first time in half a century he made a few factual errors. However historian Matthias Reiss was sceptical and passionate in his view that any flawed accounts of the Holocaust needed to be fully verified to avoid playing into the hands of the deniers.

We saw Avey talk to a group of pensioners, some of them Holocaust survivors, at a day-care centre in Manchester. One of them, Dorka Samson, clearly believed him. “God only bless him how he managed to do it,” she said.

Ultimately, whether his book is 100 per cent accurate or not, Avey came across as a brave and upright man who risked his life to save Jews and remained traumatise­d by the experience.

 ??  ??
 ?? PHOTO: BBC PICTURES ?? Suburban sitcom: Simon Amstell with his on-screen Jewish family
PHOTO: BBC PICTURES Suburban sitcom: Simon Amstell with his on-screen Jewish family
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom