The Jewish Chronicle

Hillel leader killed in horror crash

- BY ANSHEL PFEFFER

A YOUNG Jewish woman was among the 224 people killed when a Russian plane crashed in the Sinai Peninsula last Saturday morning.

Anna Tishinskay­a, 27, was on the chartered flight travelling from Sharm el-Sheikh, a popular resort, to St Petersburg in Russia.

The former St Petersburg State University student, who read history, was the former director of Jewish student organisati­on Hillel Russia. Organisati­on leaders expressed horror at the news, describing Ms Tishinskay­a as “part of the family.

“Anya, you were incredibly talented, swift, fearless, sincere, kind and bright. You were a truly extraordin­ary person.”

Mystery still surrounds the circumstan­ces of the crash. The local affiliate of Daesh claims to have shot the plane down, while both Egyptian and Russian authoritie­s are dismissing this.

The fact that the wreckage was scattereda­crosseight­squaremile­sof desert, however, indicates that the plane could have broken up in mid-flight, which would point to an explosion.

After take-off, the Kogalymavi­a Airbus A321 had climbed to 33,000 ft before it rapidly lost height, crashing about 20 miles south of El Arish.

There are conflictin­g reports about whether the pilots had called air-traffic control to notify them of an emergency and request landing in an alternativ­e airfield. The flight recorders have been

The remains of the Russian airline and ( retrieved and are being analysed by Russian authoritie­s.

Since the Airbus A320 family has an excellent safety record, a structural issue is unlikely. The claims made by the Sinai branch of Daesh that it shot down the plane are also questionab­le since the organisati­on is only known to have small shoulder-launched anti-aircraft missiles, incapable of hitting a target

Anna Tishinskay­a at over 11,000 ft. Two more plausible explanatio­ns for the crash would be poor maintenanc­e, which could have led to a fault in one of the engines, or a fire. There have been reports that in the days leading up to the accident, the pilots had spoken about maintenanc­e problems with the aircraft.

Anotherpos­sibilitywo­uldbethemi­dflight detonation of a bomb stowed on the plane. The Egyptian government is anxious that the crash is not seen as a result of a terror act, as they fear that one of their few remaining sources of income — Russian tourists flying to the Sinai beach resorts — could dry up.

 ?? PHOTO: REUTERS ?? right)
PHOTO: REUTERS right)
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom