Corbyn backs Marxist activist who ‘monstered Jews’
JEREMY CORBYN “raised concerns” about Labour’s decision to expel the anti-Israel activist whose controversial essay about the Nazis and Zionists was distributed at party conference, the JC can reveal.
It is understood the Labour leader complained in October 2017 to then General Secretary Iain McNicol about the expulsion of Moshé Machover, who was later readmitted, after receiving “many complaints from members”.
Mr Machover’s article quoted Reinhard Heydrich, the architect of the Final Solution, to advance the notion that the Nazis supported Zionists before the Holocaust.
The revelation comes amid an ongoing storm for the Labour leadership as interventions by Mr Corbyn’s office in disciplinary cases have emerged, contrary to assurances.
Labour sources confirmed that Mr Corbyn’s office was involved in Mr Machover’s case but insisted staff made the decision to reverse his expulsion, not the leader himself.
Mr Machover, a member of Hampand stead and Kilburn CLP, wrote an article distributed at the 2017 Labour conference in Brighton. In it he argued that a “campaign of equating opposition to Zionism with antisemitism has, in fact, been carefully orchestrated with the help of the Israeli government”. The essay — ‘Anti-Zionism does not equal antisemitism’ — quoted Heydrich, who said in 1935: “National Socialists had no intention of attacking Jewish people in any way.”
Mr Machover also quoted Heydrich’s preShoah claim that the Nazi government was “in complete agreement with the great spiritual movement within Jewry itself, so-called Zionism”.
Mr Machover wrote that Heydrich had offered “a friendly mention of Zionism, indicating an area of basic agreement it shared with Nazism”.
The article appeared in a magazine produced by the Labour Party Marxists group, which is closely linked to the Communist Party of Great Britain.
At the time, Labour’s John Mann Holocaust Educational Trust Chief Executive Karen Pollock both attacked publication of the article and called for those linked to the group to be expelled from the party.
David Hirsh, a senior lecturer at Goldsmiths, University of London, accused Mr Machover of “monstering of Jews and of Israel” with the Heydrich quote.
Dr Hirsh said a passage in Hitler’s Mein Kampf demonises Zionism.
“There should be no place in democratic Labour politics for Mr Machover’s misrepresentation of history,” Dr Hirsh added.
In a letter from Labour’s Head of Disputes, Mr Machover was told the article “appears to meet the IHRA definition of antisemitism”.
But the Tel Aviv-born activist was told he had been “automatically excluded” from Labour because he was a member of another party, “namely Labour Party Marxists, as well as the Communist Party”.
A letter dated October 5 told him: “For the avoidance of any doubt, you are not ineligible for membership as a result of complaints received by the party that you have breached rule 2.I.8 regarding language which may be prejudicial or grossly detrimental to the party in an allegedly antisemitic article … These allegations are not subject to an investigation as you are not currently a member of the Labour Party.”
Mr Machover won the support of anti-Israel activists along with Labour left-wingers and celebrities, including musician Brian Eno.
On October 30, a new letter was sent to him, saying: “The party has reviewed the matters of fact surrounding your case and the decision has been taken to rescind your automatic exclusion.”
The letter listed the instances of him appearing to support the Communist Party, including 44 articles he wrote in its publication, some “campaigning”, and 17 videos of him speaking on its website.
“Such support is incompatible with Labour Party membership, so thank you for clarifying that this was not your intention to provide such support,” it said.
Laura Murray, Mr Corbyn’s stakeholder manager at the time, wrote: “There will still be outstanding issues on people’s minds around the reasons for his auto-exclusion, but I am glad that he is now a Labour Party member again.”
But only now has it been confirmed that Mr Corbyn was among those to argue Mr Machover be reinstated.
Since the furore over Mr Machover’s article, he has continued to make controversial remarks. In an interview with a US online news channel, he said the “pro-Israel lobby” was exploiting the legacy of the Holocaust to try to silence criticism of the country.
When asked about Mr Corbyn’s intervention over Mr Machover’s expulsion from Labour, a party source told the JC Mr Machover’s initial exclusion was “not in relation to any allegations of antisemitism”.
“Machover, an eminent Jewish Israeli academic, was not a member of another political party, so should not have been auto-excluded. Members of the leader’s office raised concerns about this misapplication of the party’s rules.”
The Nazis were in agreement with Zionism’