Westminster Holocaust Memorial in the balance as government lodges appeal against legal block
THE GOVERNMENT has lodged an appeal against the High Court decision to block the planned national Holocaust Memorial next to the Houses of Parliament.
The legal move, which came last Friday, was just the latest twist in a long-running planning battle.
At the start of last month, a legal challenge to the £100 million project succeeded as a judge quashed planning permission for the memorial and learning centre.
Mrs Justice Thornton ruled there was “an enduring obligation to retain the new garden land as a public garden and integral part of the existing Victoria Tower Gardens”.
She said the structure would represent an “exceptionally serious intrusion into a green public open space of the highest heritage significance”.
The creation of a prominent National Memorial was proposed in 2015 by a Holocaust Commission, which was created by then-Prime Minister David Cameron the previous year.
Announcing the government’s appeal last week, a spokesperson for the Levelling Up, Housing and Communities department said: “We remain completely committed to constructing the Memorial at this location, which was carefully selected to reflect its national significance — next to Parliament and close to other important memorials including the Cenotaph.
“We owe a lasting memorial not just to Holocaust survivors, but to the British
people now and for generations to come.” The official said the lack of a prominent memorial to the Shoah in Britain has been a source of concern for many survivors and their families. The government is determined to deliver on a “Promise to Remember”, they added, in a reference to the 2015 cross-party report that initially proposed the memorial.
The structure is backed by the Board of Deputies and the Chief Rabbi, but opposed by many others within the community.
Responding to the High Court
ruling, Rabbi Dr Jonathan Romain of Maidenhead Synagogue said: “We know from the resurgence of antisemitism in countries abroad with powerful Holocaust museums that buildings do not change minds: it will be far better for the UK to use the £100 million to have an education programme in schools nationally than a Londoncentric memorial.”
Karen Pollock, chief executive of the Holocaust Educational Trust, said: “Many hope to see the opening of the Holocaust Memorial and Learning Centre standing proudly next to Parliament, serving as a warning from history of what can happen when antisemitism and hate is left unchecked. This memorial will stand as a reminder for generations to come.”
The UK Holocaust Memorial and Learning Centre, initially set to open in 2024, would commemorate the six million Jewish people murdered in the Holocaust, alongside the Roma, gay people and the disabled.
The Learning Centre would also seek to reflect on subsequent genocides in Cambodia, Rwanda, Bosnia and Darfur.
The location was selected to reflect its national significance
It is backed by the Chief Rabbi but opposed by many in the community