Act now to keep Jewish pupils safe
As shock report reveals school incidents of antisemitism trebled in 5 years, politicians urge Government:
Pupils mocked by references to the Nazis and the Holocaust
▶ ANTISEMITIC INCIDENTS at secondary schools have almost trebled over the past five years, according to a bombshell new report.
The findings, published today exclusively in the JC, also reveal that almost no schools have policies to combat the tide of hate.
More than 1,000 incidents have been uncovered by an unprecedented largescale investigation using Freedom of Information (FoI) requests.
These included 76 instances judged so serious teachers reported them to police. There were 13 physical assaults.
The alarming report also revealed that fewer than one in 20 schools have a policy to deal with antisemitism.
Both Tory and Labour politicians reacted to the findings by calling for the Government to introduce mandatory antisemitism policies at all schools.
Researchers at the Henry Jackson Society (HJS) think tank made FoI submissions to more than 3,000 secondary schools in England.
Of these, 1,314 schools — about 40 per cent — responded.
One question asked how many incidents involving pupil misconduct, bullying, harassment, or similar events in which the term “antisemitism” was recorded had taken place over the past five years.
The number of incidents reported for 2017 to 2022 totalled 1,030.
There were 60 incidents in 2017. This year, the figure almost trebled to 164. A further 581 incidents were logged but not linked to a specific year within the five-year period.
Taking into account how many schools did not respond and the fact that those that did are likely to be better at dealing with antisemitism, the overall total is almost certainly far higher.
Community workers confirmed to the JC that the numbers reported represent just a small fraction of the totals.
The HJS researchers also found that just 47 schools have any kind of formal, written policy that might make staff more aware of the vicious forms antisemitic bullying often takes, or require them to crack down on it.
The figure represents a derisory 3.4 per cent of schools that reported back.
Some of the schools in the survey shared details of individual cases. Of these, 58 per cent involved mockery and abuse of Jewish students through references to the Nazis and the Holocaust.
The list of disturbing incidents includes the practice of hissing at Jewish students to emulate the supposed sound of Nazi gas chambers.
Such taunting has taken place immediately after Holocaust education classes in some schools, community sources have told the JC.
The HJS report recounts how at a
PHYSICAL ASSAULTS: 13 (NO YEAR-BY-YEAR BREAKDOWN) TOTAL OF ALL INCIDENTS REFERRED TO POLICE: 79 TOTAL RECORDED ANTISEMITIC INCIDENTS 2017-2022: 1,077 173% RISE OVER 5 YEARS: 29% RISE IN LAST YEAR:
school in Sussex, non-Jewish pupils made the hissing sound in a science lab as they turned on Bunsen burners.
Schools’ incident reports submitted in response to the FoI request reveal antisemitism across the country: •In
Cumbria, a student brought in a copy of Hitler’s Mein Kampf and suggested his class read it together as a set text. Another pupil at the same school asked questions during a personal development lesson about the “Jewish conspiracy” that runs the world;
•At a school in east London, a pupil threw a drink over a Jewish classmate while delivering antisemitic abuse;
•There were three separate incidents at a school in Norfolk. One pupil was referred to Prevent for using “racist and threatening language” in class towards both Jews and other minorities, another expressed “unacceptable views about Nazis” in a piece of creative writing written from the perspective of a Nazi concentration camp guard, and a third student was referred to Prevent after scrawling swastikas and pro-Nazi graffiti on a classroom whiteboard;
•At a school in Lancashire, a swastika was drawn on a classroom wall at a school where a pupil was also heard
It’s hard to believe that this can still be happening in 2022 in Britain
Experts fear that all too many incidents are not reported
making antisemitic comments in relation to the Israel-Hamas conflict.
Senior politicians from both of the main parties called for immediate action.
Tory MP Robert Halfon, chairman of the Commons Select Committee on Education, told the
JC: “This is horrific.
It’s hard to believe that in 2022, Jewish students are being subjected to antisemitism and abuse of this kind — and yet nothing seems to be being done about it.”
Mr Halfon said he would be raising the issue in the Commons, and that he plans to table an Early Day Motion.
Urging the Education Secretary “to introduce severe sanctions against schools who fail to deal with it”, he said: “It isn’t just a matter of education and training but culture, and he has to create the conditions where Jewish students feel safe in their schools. In the worst-affected schools, the Secretary of State should be calling head teachers individually and demanding to know what they are going to do about it.”
Bridget Phillipson, Labour’s Shadow Secretary of State for Education, told the JC: “Antisemitism is an evil that must be tackled at every level and in every part of our society.
This survey has left me shocked and appalled, and the number of incidents is rising quickly.
“It’s crucial that the government acts fast to ensure that anti-racism policies are accompanied with clear guidance for teachers and school leaders on recognising antisemitism at school — in the playground and the corridor, as well as in the classroom — and on dealing with it.”
The HJS report said: “The high number of incidents reported at certain schools compared to zero incidents reported at others points towards a lack of a standardised reporting approach. A standardised approach is
NUMBER OF INCIDENTS YEAR-BY-YEAR: 2017-2018: 58 2018-2019: 76 2019-2020: 56 2020-2021: 106 2021-2022: 165
581 2017-22 (NO SPECIFIC YEAR):
likely to see a much greater number of incidences reported.”
The report urges schools to adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Association (IHRA) definition of antisemitism, which has already been endorsed by all mainstream political parties and numerous public bodies. It says that this will also help to raise awareness and improve the accuracy of incident recording.
The JC has uncovered further antisemitic incidents that were never reported to teachers because the victims and their families had lost all trust in the schools involved.
They include the case of a teenage girl who became so distressed at the constant hatred directed at her purely because she was Jewish at her local school in south London that she now spends several hours every day travelling to and from a Jewish school on the other side of the capital. The JC has learned of two cases where Jewish teachers have experienced such intense antisemitism from their own students that they have resigned, rather than continue to put up with it. Both are suing their former employers, arguing that the discrimination they faced and their schools’ failure to put a stop to it amounted to constructive dismissal.
The report highlights that “incidences of antisemitism have been on a steep incline unchecked” yet “never been shared with a public body for monitoring purposes”.
The authors suggest that as well as making antisemitism policies mandatory, the Government should ensure official education watchdog Ofsted assess antisemitism in inspections, and “require all schools to report the number of incidences of antisemitism (as outlined in the IHRA definition) to the Department of Education annually” for it to publish annual figures.
Th figures for 2020–21 were more than double the previous year, up from 59 to 127.
There was a further rise of almost a third in the year up until now, to 164.
The steep rise may be linked to the May 2021 conflict between Israel and Hamas, the report suggests. The overall increase in the annual totals since 2017 is 173 per cent.
One school in London catalogued 29 incidents – the most of any school. The next 10 schools for the highest figures are in Hampshire, Essex, Bristol, West Sussex, Kent, Norfolk, Cornwall, Manchester, Berkshire and Surrey.
In all, 290 schools that responded to the survey recorded at least one antisemitic incident.
JUST 47 OF THE 1,314 SCHOOLS THAT RESPONDED SAY THEY HAVE ANTISEMITISM POLICIES TO RECOGNISE AND DEAL WITH THE PROBLEM, OR 3.4 PER CENT OF THE TOTAL
Sharp increase linked at least in part to war of Israel and Hamas in 2021