Record £187,000 fines and costs for Oban fishing firm

The owners and master of two scallop dredging vessels have been prosecuted for ‘multiple’ fishing offences off the Yorkshire coast.

The master of the Star of Annan OB50, Alec Murray, of Upper Bayble, Isle of Lewis, was ordered to pay £3,633.

But the owner of the vessel, John MacAlister (Oban) Ltd of South Pier, Oban, was ordered to pay a total of £187,170 in fines and associated costs.

MacAlister and Murray pleaded guilty at an earlier hearing to 10 offences which took place between March 4 and May 28 2019.

The prosecutions were brought by the North Eastern Inshore Fisheries & Conservation Authority (NEIFCA), which acts as an enforcement and compliance organisation.

Offences included operating in a closed season; using scallop dredges without the authority of a permit; exceeding the permitted number of dredges; failing to operate a fully functioning vessel identification system and landing under-sized scallops.

Mitigation put forward included unfamiliarity with local regulations.

MacAlister also appeared as a director representing a company called Q Varl Fishing Co Ltd based in Torquay.

It was ordered to pay £17,310 in fines and associated costs relating to two similar offences committed by its fishing vessel Q Varl BM29 in the same area between May 27 and June 4 2019, but under a different skipper.

A warrant for the arrest of that vessel’s skipper was issued after he failed to appear at the court hearing.

David McCandless, chief inshore fisheries and conservation officer at the NEIFCA, welcomed the magistrates’ decision.

Disregard

He said it reflected both the level of offending and the ‘blatant’ disregard shown for local regulations.

It represented a ‘record’ fine and costs for the NEIFCA organisation, with its previous largest fine being around £30,000, he said, adding that it is also the largest fine issued across the whole inshore authority area - the previous being £65,000.

It is not known if an appeal will be lodged.

At the sentencing hearing at Scarborough Magistrates Court, the bench found that there had been a ‘deliberate failure’ to put in place and to enforce such systems as could reasonably be expected in all the circumstances to avoid commission of the offences.

The court also acknowledged the ‘significant’ associated impacts of the offending

One of the images provided as evidence during the court case.