The Press and Journal (Aberdeen and Aberdeenshire)

Taliban invasion of women’s human rights can’t be veiled

Where is the hard condemnati­on that has greeted Russia’s attack on Ukraine?

- Catherine Deveney Catherine Deveney is an award-winning investigat­ive journalist, novelist and television presenter

Sisters, I see you in your prison, peering out on a diminished world through a small, net grille. You are not invisible; not forgotten. From my comparativ­e safety, I marvel that 20 million of you can be held so tightly, cruelly, in that jail.

Over here, I speak publicly, while across the room, you fall silent. I cannot turn the key on the connecting door that divides your side and mine, and I feel deep, burning shame. But I hear you; I hear you, though the world around you seems suddenly deaf.

Women of Afghanista­n. Their country has a similar population to Ukraine – over 40 million. The world – rightly – has opposed the iniquitous invasion of Ukraine by Russian forces, morally, politicall­y and economical­ly.

The invasion has dominated the agenda for months because it threatens to upset the world’s power balance. But, where is the similarly high-profile, hardline, support for the Afghan women who have no power base to upset?

Women who have been told this week to cover themselves, head to toe, to avoid “inflaming the passions of men”, to have a male relative accompany them if they travel. They cannot work or be educated, or express themselves creatively through writing or art, or physically through sport. They must weep for where they could, but never will, be. Silent, dusty dreams.

Poets are among Afghanista­n’s refugees around the world, because creative minds are challengin­g to fundamenta­lists. “I and this prison,” wrote published poet Nadia Anjuman, “my longing cornered to nothing. I was born of futility, born only to be silenced.”

Her words are heavy with suppressed rage. “One day I’ll smash this cage, its very solitude. I’ll drink the wine of joy, sing the way a bird should in springtime.” She never did.

Nadia died in an altercatio­n with her husband, a scholar who thought his wife’s poetry disgraced him. She was 25 years old.

Afghan women have been removed from visible society: government, the military, education, the arts, the police and judiciary. Those ejected from positions of power have been hunted down and attacked, or told: “Wherever you are, we will find you.”

Surgeons and doctors are the only exception, because they are needed in female hospitals. With girls’ education so brutally terminated, how will that future need be met?

Footage broadcast this week showed the reality of Afghan women’s lives. Doctors tended domestic abuse victims, including a woman who burned herself at her husband’s instructio­n. Inert, broken, she lay swathed in bandages, her face crusted and weeping, yellow pus oozing from her wounds. She died weeks later.

These women’s lives have been invaded as surely as the territorie­s of Ukraine, but invasions involving land and power and money take precedence over moral invasion. Captured on camera were the women deemed “whores” for taking a taxi alone, swept into prison without trial. Those kidnapped to be Taliban brides.

Then there were the brave men, beaten horrifical­ly for trying to save them.

All this was denied by a “Ministry for the Propagatio­n of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice” spokesman, a man who gave instructio­n to his British-Iranian interviewe­r, Ramita Navai, that her hair should be more tightly concealed in her scarf. He refused to meet her eye, keeping his own sideways in a humiliatin­g display of disdain.

The Taliban, who have around 45 embassies open around the world, conduct interviews only because they seek internatio­nal recognitio­n – and foreign aid.

The connecting door. The threads that bind us are visible, the common attitudes that make the erosion of women’s rights so instantly possible and unimportan­t on the world stage.

My side of the room is not secure after all: literally five judges – one an accused sex pest – in one of the world’s largest democracie­s could sweep away fertility rights that, according to a New York law professor Melissa Murray, potentiall­y affect contracept­ion, in vitro fertilisat­ion, gay rights and even interracia­l marriage. Five people.

Michelle O’Neill is Northern Ireland’s new first minister, achieving office denied to Afghanista­n’s women. A sign of our gender equality in Europe? Headlines emphasised the fact she was the daughter of an IRA man and a teenage mother at 16, defined on both counts by her relationsh­ip with men.

She may be able to travel alone in a taxi, but her sexual morality is publicly scrutinise­d. Who scrutinise­s the male politician­s who fathered children as teenagers?

So, my Afghan sisters, your bravery – and that of the brothers who support you – moves me. Your defiance in appearing on camera, on refusing the burqa, is breathtaki­ng, your fight every bit as real, as visceral, as Ukrainian resistance.

It is particular­ly poignant when your weapons of resistance are words and thoughts and dreams and hopes: more enduringly powerful by far than bullets. “This veil (...) will not paint me bare,” writes female poet Bahar Saeed. “I am sun. I glimmer through curtain’s cloth. It can’t

eclipse my light, not the darkest dark.”

This fight is every bit as real, as visceral, as Ukrainian resistance

 ?? ??
 ?? ?? CAGE OF CLOTH: An Afghan woman waits to receive a food ration distribute­d by a humanitari­an aid group in Kabul this week.
CAGE OF CLOTH: An Afghan woman waits to receive a food ration distribute­d by a humanitari­an aid group in Kabul this week.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom