The Scotsman

Yes, a Glasgow School of Art rebuilt to Mackintosh’s design would be authentic

-

Professor Alan Dunlop says a reconstruc­ted GSOA would not be authentic (your report, 18 June). Why?

Charles Rennie Mackintosh did not build the original school, he designed it and it was built by constructi­on workers and craftsmen. Mackintosh’s design is still available. There can’t be a single detail in the building that has not been minutely examined, photograph­ed and recorded.

It is often said that “they don’t build them like that any more”, but the reconstruc­tion carried out before the second fire demonstrat­es that the necessary skills still exist. If the GSOA was rebuilt by today’s constructi­on workers, using Mackintosh’s design, the process would be exactly as it was originally. In what way would that not be authentic? The professor’s remark seems defeatist and designed to prepare us for some cheap mediocre new building on the site. GRAHAM M MCLEOD

Muirs, Kinross To lose Glasgow School of Art so tragically to fire four years ago was unfortunat­e but, as Lady Bracknell might put it, to lose it for a second time sounds like carelessne­ss – even more sorrowful this time coming as it does in the Mackintosh 150th anniversar­y year.

Holyrood ought to see the importance of earnest attention to the Scottish Government’s Ministeria­l creation of a single force Fire Service and ensure it is adequately funded and consider, too, whether fire regulation­s are up to the job in today’s circumstan­ces. Recent months have already witnessed fires at Cameron House on the shores of Loch Lomond and at the other end of Glasgow’s Sauchiehal­l Street which have impacted on other businesses.

JIM CRAIGEN Downie Grove, Edinburgh Suggestion for the SQA Art and Design Higher Examinatio­n Paper 2019.

The Glasgow School of Art was rebuilt over four years at a cost of £35 million.there were no water sprinklers installed. Discuss the design of the reconstruc­tion. 25 marks.

JOHN V LLOYD The Maltings, Keith Place

Inverkeith­ing, Fife

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom