Unfair change

Is discrimination wrong? If so, how can the government of a progressive western society justify using it as a means of saving money?

The Non-domestic Rates (Scotland) Bill is due for final debate in the Scottish Parliament on 4 February, yet this shocking abuse of trust is sailing through largely unnoticed, removing much-needed rates relief from all independent schools in Scotland, with the exception of “special schools”.

This demeans a small but essential part of the charities sector – all other charities will still enjoy rates relief. Why are the Scottish Government proposing a scheme that will put intolerable financial burdens on independent schools, undoubtedly leading to closure and thereby adding pressure on the state schooling system?

My children have been fortunate enough to attend an independent Christian school and enjoy an excellent education based on the national curriculum, but without the unsavoury distractions associated with state schools. The inevitable closure of some independent schools is a tragedy. Why should a Christian school not enjoy the same rates relief as a music school?

If our school closes, where can children go without violating our Christian beliefs?

CRAIG MICHEL

Perth Road Abernethy, Perth

Our grandchildren attend a small, local Christian school in Balmedie, and I am concerned as to the Scottish Government’s Bill to remove rates relief from independent schools such as ours. The school is a faith-based school, drawing students from a wide range of families at varying income levels. Budgets are well managed and fee reduction support is provided for those who need it. There is a very happy environment throughout the whole school.

Why does the Scottish Government need to target such small minority schools?

A simple provision could be made in the Bill to provide exemption from the removal of rates relief. Committee members and ministers – please go ahead and make it.

GRAHAM WHITBOURN North Beach Road, Balmedie