Sarwar demands scrapping of 40-year-old trains after fatal crash
Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar has joined train drivers in calling for the 40-yearold Scotrail fleet involved in the fatal Carmont crash to be scrapped.
He told First Minister Nicola Sturgeon that allowing such trains to operate which did not meet current safety standards should be “corrected immediately” once Scotrail was taken into Scottish Government control in three weeks’ time.
Mr Sarwar told MSPS at First Minister’s Questions: “The train that was operating on this route was decades old. They were first introduced into service in the mid-’70s and didn’t comply with safety standards set in 1994.
"We should not have allowed unsafe trains or trains that did not meet standards to be on our railways.”
The UK Department for Transport’s Rail Accident Investigation Branch’s (RAIB) final report into the crash near Stonehaven in Aberdeenshire, in which three people were killed, said it was “more likely than not that the outcome would have been better if the train had been compliant with modern crashworthiness standards”.
The body compared the crash to the 95mph derailment of a newer Pendolino train in Cumbria in 2007, in which one passenger was killed and 30 injured.
Investigators said they did not regards “High Speed Trains” (HSTS) to be unsafe, but their report made seven recommendations for safety improvements, including stronger “lifeguard” [metal
brackets] to better protect the wheels from obstacles, safer window glass, and replacing batteries in carriages that were less likely to catch fire.
Train drivers union Aslef has demanded the refurbished HSTS are withdrawn by the third anniversary of the crash in August next year.
The fleet of 25 trains operate on Scotrail’s “Inter7city” routes between Edinburgh/ Glasgow and Aberdeen/inverness. LNER withdrew its HSTS,
which operated between Aberdeen, Inverness and London, in 2019.
Gareth Dennis, a rail engineer who has also called for them to be taken out of service, said: “My analysis that the consequences of this derailment could have been considerably less had it involved trains with modern safety features was challenged at the time from some quarters.
"The RAIB report is explicit in confirming that ‘the out
come would have been better if the train had been compliant withmoderncrashworthiness standards’ and it makes several recommendations to mitigate the risks of running older trains in passenger service.”
Manuel Cortes, general secretary of the Transport Salaried Staffs Association, said: “The RAIB report is crystal clear. It is devastating to think that a different train might have given us a better outcome. These museum pieces should have been retired a long time ago.”
However, Ms Sturgeon said the trains were “fully compliant with legal requirements to operate”.
Transport minister Jenny Gilruth later told MSPS that a Transport Scotland-led steering group would be established “to take forward implementation of the recommendations”.