The Scottish Mail on Sunday

Why don’t you want our children to have as good an education as you, Nick?

- Peter Hitchens DEBATE WITH PETER HITCHENS – GO TO http://hitchensbl­og.mailonsund­ay.co.uk

IBN A horrible, ignorant speech last week, the Deputy Prime Minister revealed himself as a limited, conformist slave to convention­al wisdom. He is also a wretched, skulking hypocrite, as I shall explain later. He ought to know better. Thinking people of Left and Right have at last begun to see that comprehens­ive state schools have failed the country, and, above all, have failed the children of the poor.

Even veteran radical commentato­rs such as Nick Cohen and Mary Ann Sieghart see the sense in selection by ability.

But Mr Clegg is demanding that our great universiti­es should be ruined by the same egalitaria­n dogma that has wrecked secondary schooling.

Put simply, he wants the best colleges to lower their entry requiremen­ts. This will, of course, increase the number of state school pupils who get in. And it will reduce the numbers from private schools.

It is easy to sympathise with this, if you forget that it will also mean that university standards will fall, irrecovera­bly. It should not be possible to buy privilege in education. It is obvious that ability and merit alone should be our guide. UT that is exactly where we were heading in this country until the Left-liberal levellers got to work. Mr Clegg thinks that ‘little has changed’ in the past 50 years. Oh yes it has. It has got much worse, thanks to people like him.

In 1965, just before most grammar schools and Scottish academies were abolished, 57 per cent of places at Oxford University were taken by pupils from state grammar schools or direct grant schools (independen­t schools that gave large numbers of free places on merit, a fine system done away with in 1975 in another wave of vindictive Leftist spite).

What is more important, the number of state school entrants was rising rapidly, and had done ever since 1945, when the grammar schools were opened to all who could qualify.

No special concession­s were made in those days. The grammar school boys and girls were there by absolute right. These brilliant people still hold high positions in every profession and activity.

But after 1965, the flow dried up, and instead of having a proper, qualified elite, we had to make do with privileged ninnies such as Mr Clegg instead. Either they had gone to hugely expensive private schools, as he did, or they arrived at the top via the rich, well-connected socialist’s route to privilege, a semi-secret network of excel-

TORIES should be wary about making it easier to sack people. Since they don’t do the job they claim to do, and haven’t for years, voters might get it into their heads that it is time to sack the Tory Party and replace it with something better. lent state schools, some religious, some with tiny catchment areas where most people cannot afford to live, some with other elaborate arrangemen­ts to keep out the masses.

These schools – the Roman Catholic London Oratory that atheist Mr Clegg has visited as a prospectiv­e parent is an example – are officially com- prehensive. But, in fact, they are comprehens­ive in the same way that 10 Downing Street is an inner-city terrace house.

What does Mr Clegg plan to do for his children? Does he plan to toss them into a bogstandar­d comp, where they will have to struggle to learn from demoralise­d supply teachers amid the shouting, the mobile phone calls and the fights?

Will he then feel his parental duty has been done if, despite the fact that they know very little, they are given privileged access to Oxbridge, but are unable to benefit from its rigour? I doubt it.

He won’t talk about it. He thinks it’s none of our business. Well, he is wrong. He has made it our business by supporting and defending a system that slams the gates of good schools in the faces of all those who are not rich.

BICYCLING through an idyllic village in Cameron country on a perfect May day, I was musing on moving there when I saw coming towards me a gross figure in jeans, T-shirt and one of those stiff-brimmed baseball caps that invariably betoken outstandin­g stupidity and aggression. A cigarette was screwed into the middle of his face. He was being towed along by a pair of slobbering weapon dogs, slightly better looking than he was. There is no escape from our nation’s moral and cultural decay. It is everywhere.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom