The Scottish Mail on Sunday

Frankel v Black Caviar? Please make it happen

- By Ed Watson

TWO unbeaten horses, one unmistakab­le opportunit­y. Indeed, the question now isn’t whether those with the vision and influence should make it happen but, rather, can racing’s rule-makers afford not to toss convention to one side and do everything within their power to turn a dream scenario into reality?

This summer, Euro 2012 and then the Olympics will apply pressure to the coverage of racing across national media in a way rarely seen before. In extreme cases, some newspaper titles may even omit racecards from their publicatio­ns to maximise column inches for both events. The implicatio­ns for racing’s profile are obvious.

But what if Frankel versus Black Caviar were to happen? The clash between the world’s highest-rated Flat horse, whose victory in last weekend’s Lockinge Stakes extended his career record to 10 wins from as many races, against the Australian wonder mare, who is a perfect 21 from 21?

The simple answer is a once-in-an-era rivalry with an appeal and marketabil­ity which would transcend way beyond the sport’s traditiona­l boundaries. Think Brigadier Gerard versus Mill Reef. Only bigger.

Many obstacles need to be negotiated for such a compelling spectacle to come to fruition. First and foremost, consent from connection­s to put their charges’ hitherto unblemishe­d records on the line. Secondly, both horses would need to emerge safely — and successful­ly — from their respective targets at Royal Ascot, plus any subsequent races.

And, thirdly, willingnes­s is required from the BHA, and other key stakeholde­rs, to create as level a playing field as possible for the two competitor­s.

Glorious Goodwood at the end of July stands out as the most suitable venue. The Sussex Stakes has been mooted as a possible meeting point but the one- mile trip would strongly favour Frankel over a sprinter like Black Caviar. In the interests of fairness and genuine sporting competitio­n, we’re crying out for the BHA and Goodwood’s management to sanction an ad hoc seven-furlong race.

They have the power to do it. Let’s hope all parties have the inclinatio­n, as well.

Whether or not potentiall­y the greatest match race in history comes to pass, this column will not be reporting on it. After seven-and-a-half years, Turf Talk has its final outing today. It has been a joy to chronicle the historic victories of Brindisi Breeze, Merigo, Big Timer and Appalachia­n Trail, the ground-breaking training achievemen­ts of Mark Johnston and the innumerabl­e positive developmen­ts at and on our five racecourse­s.

During that time, Scottish racing has also said a sad farewell to some fine horses and many even finer people. That is always the hard part of what has been an otherwise enjoyable stint in the saddle.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom