The Scottish Mail on Sunday

Whiplash ISN’T in the mind. Doc­tors just look for it in the wrong place

- By So­phie Good­child Health · Medicine · Iceland · Belarus · London · Belgium · Austria · Bangsund · Norway · Francis Smith

THOU­SANDS of pa­tients who go to doc­tors des­per­ate for help with neck pain are be­ing left in agony be­cause tra­di­tional scan­ning meth­ods are fail­ing to di­ag­nose it as whiplash, ex­perts have warned.

Too many doc­tors fail to look for in­jury in a spe­cific part of the body, known as the cran­io­cer­vi­cal junc­tion. This is an area of bone be­tween the skull and the neck that is par­tic­u­larly vul­ner­a­ble to whiplash in­jury, caused by sud­den move­ment of the head for­wards, back­wards or side­ways.

The dam­age does not al­ways show be­cause stan­dard brain scans stop above this junc­tion, and nor­mal neck imag­ing ends below it.

Dr Steve Morgan, from the Med­ser­ena Up­right MRI Cen­tre in Lon­don, said: ‘It’s not an area com­monly scanned with rou­tine MRIs. The re­sult is that in­juries aren’t be­ing de­tected so peo­ple are suf­fer­ing, some­times for years.’

Com­mon causes of whiplash in­clude road ac­ci­dents, a sud­den blow to the head – dur­ing sports such as box­ing or rugby – and a slip or fall where the head is jolted back.

Symp­toms in­clude headaches as well as pain in the neck, shoul­ders and arms. Less com­monly, a pa­tient can suf­fer pins and nee­dles in the arms and hands, dizzi­ness, tired­ness, mem­ory loss, poor con­cen­tra­tion and ir­ri­tabil­ity.

The di­ag­no­sis of whiplash in­jury has be­come con­tro­ver­sial, af­ter a dou­bling in the num­ber of com­pen­sa­tion claims re­lated to the con­di­tion in the past decade, many sus- pected to be ex­ag­ger­ated and fraud­u­lent. In re­sponse, the Govern­ment has an­nounced a clam­p­down. Re­forms in­clude a £5,000 claims limit for whiplash, with a £2,000 thresh­old re­lat­ing to other per­sonal in­jury claims. A to­tal ban on per­sonal in­jury claims with­out med­i­cal ev­i­dence has also been pro­posed.

Many more pa­tients are told there is ‘noth­ing wrong’ af­ter scans fail to pick up an in­jury. Dr Morgan says whiplash is ‘a very real prob­lem’ and is call­ing for more pa­tients with per­sis­tent neck pain to be re­ferred to spe­cial­ists.

MEAN­WHILE, an on­go­ing study by Pro­fes­sor Francis Smith, a pi­o­neer of MRI scans, has shown that tra­di­tional scan­ning prac­tices are in­ad­e­quate when it comes to pick­ing up whiplash in­juries. It con­cludes that thor­ough MRI ex­am­i­na­tion of the neck is nec­es­sary, es­pe­cially of the cran­io­cer­vi­cal junc­tion, the com­plex area of lig­a­ments and tough tis­sues that con­nect the top of the spine to the skull. Many sur­geons look in­stead for prob­lems with the in­ter­ver­te­bral discs.

Prof Smith said: ‘In more than 200 pa­tients suf­fer­ing sus­pected whiplash in­jury that we’ve now scanned, about 60 to 70 per cent have pre­vi­ously un­recog­nised prob­lems at the cran­io­cer­vi­cal junc­tion.’

If the in­jury is de­tected, a sim­ple sur­gi­cal pro­ce­dure can be car­ried out to sta­bilise the joint, us­ing a screw-like im­plant.

Fa­ther-of-two Odd Bang­sund, 53, spent years nearly 20 years on painkiller­s for con­stant headaches, and suf­fered de­pres­sion, af­ter a mo­tor­bike ac­ci­dent in 1996.

X-rays failed to de­tect an in­jury, as did a rou­tine MRI scan. ‘I felt pow­er­less be­cause I was in lots of pain around my head and neck but noth­ing showed up in the scans,’ said the grand­fa­ther-of-three from Aamot in Nor­way.

In 2014, he fi­nally had surgery af­ter an up­right MRI scan at the Med­ser­ena clinic. The scan, car­ried out when he was stand­ing up rather than ly­ing flat, re­vealed he had se­vere whiplash. His spinal cord was se­verely com­pressed and the ac­ci­dent had also caused ma­jor dam­age to his cran­io­cer­vi­cal junc­tion lig­a­ments.

The scan­ner de­tected the whiplash be­cause as he was scanned stand­ing up, his head could be moved back into po­si­tions to re­veal the in­juries. He said: ‘The pain is much bet­ter now but I’ve suf­fered long-term dam­age be­cause it took years to get treat­ment.’ tru­ly­open­

 ??  ?? NO HELP: Ed­ina from Ab­so­lutely Fab­u­lous sports a neck brace – but ex­perts say that this won’t cure whiplash
NO HELP: Ed­ina from Ab­so­lutely Fab­u­lous sports a neck brace – but ex­perts say that this won’t cure whiplash

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from UK