The Scottish Mail on Sunday

Is it really fair, right or just to extradite Assange?

-

TOMORROW, the American demand for the extraditio­n of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange finally comes to the point of decision. The US authoritie­s will seek the right to take Mr Assange to stand trial.

If extradited, Mr Assange loses many of the protection­s an English defendant would have, such as legal aid and our ban on plea-bargaining, often used to force guilty pleas. He faces a colossally long sentence, quite possibly spent in a ‘supermax’ prison.

Some will be tempted to say ‘serves him right’. Mr Assange’s revelation­s of leaked material caused grave embarrassm­ent to Washington and are alleged to have done material damage too. Mr Assange has been a spectacula­r nuisance during his time in this country, lawlessly jumping bail and wasting police time by taking refuge in the embassy of Ecuador. The Mail on Sunday disapprove­s of much of what he has done, but we must also ask if his current treatment is fair, right or just.

Two considerab­le issues are raised here. The first is the unfairness of our extraditio­n treaty with the US, a relic of the Blair era.

It is plainly unequal, giving Washington astonishin­g powers to seize

UK citizens. Theresa May, when

Home Secretary, rightly defied it in the 2012 case of another hacker, Gary McKinnon.

And the charges against Mr Assange, using the American Espionage Act, might be used against legitimate journalist­s in this country. Both the courts and the current Home Secretary Priti Patel must be very wary about perpetuati­ng and upholding an unequal law such as this.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom