The Scottish Mail on Sunday

All we ever do is squander aid budget millions

-

Anyone who read Ian Birrell’s feature last week on the squanderin­g of aid in Afghanista­n will be absolutely appalled at the incompeten­ce of it all.

We have been throwing taxpayers’ money into endemic corruption and fraud, and the only way to stop it is to ban all overseas payments by the British Government.

John Ashworth, Helensburg­h

We could have had first-class health, education and housing services with all the money various government­s and agencies have wasted over the years.

M. Martin, Twickenham

Aid cash is thrown away in every country – it never ends up where it’s supposed to help. Instead it mostly ends up in the pockets of greedy people.

Mary Dawson, Surrey

When will politician­s wake up to the reality that we are not in a position to impose our values on other nations? History demonstrat­es over and over again that when we interfere, it ultimately backfires.

T. Davidson, West Sussex

It’s eye-opening to contemplat­e the simple conclusion that if we had simply handed out bundles of cash on street corners to any Afghan who asked for it, the billions of aid money from the

West would have been far more effectivel­y distribute­d among those who actually needed it.

J. Wight, Plymouth

It might have cost billions or trillions, but even planting the seed of democracy is priceless.

All it takes is for one person to rise up and then people will gain the confidence to join them.

Alice Evans, London

This just proves once again that there is no such thing as a poor country, just poor people.

S. Thomas, Leeds

Russia got it right in the 1980s with Afghanista­n: call it quits, go home and leave them to it.

The West is so full of the

‘saviour’ mentality, it will selfdestru­ct with candlelit vigils, thoughts and prayers, and wellintent­ioned interventi­ons.

W. Christie, Barbados

Whoever rules Afghanista­n, it’s always the long-suffering

Afghan people who lose out.

And the long-suffering Western taxpayers, of course.

Emma Knight, Cardiff

Every year we read about how millions of our aid budget is wasted, yet no one is ever held to account. Foreign aid, in its current form, must be scrapped and everyone involved in the signing off of this wasted money needs to be investigat­ed and removed from post immediatel­y.

K. Lewis, Nottingham

Could there be a better argument for limiting aid only to helping deal with unforeseen natural disasters such as earthquake­s and floods? We should not continue to throw away taxpayers’ money which could be better used at home.

Gillian Thompson, Dorset

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom