The Scottish Mail on Sunday

Games for trans people would be fairer to all

-

Well said Sarah Vine in her article last week about how unfair it was for American transgende­r swimmer Lia Thomas to be allowed to set a record in the

US’s Ivy League university swimming championsh­ips.

Of course, transgende­r women competing in female competitio­ns brings with it built-in advantage for them. It is unfair. Does anyone think flyweight boxers should fight heavyweigh­ts?

Why not have the National Lottery fund a Games just for the trans community? That would make it a level playing field.

Tony Carmedy, Navenby, Lincolnshi­re

Sadly, members of the LGBT+ community continue to face mistrust and hatred on a regular basis.

It is fortunate that Neil

Kinnock’s grandchild, Milo Kinnock, who has recently changed gender, is not related to your columnist Sarah Vine, who takes such great exception to the American trans athlete Lia Thomas competing against women. Vine’s assessment that her participat­ion makes ‘a mockery… of women’s sport’ is mean-spirited, ill-informed and divisive. Keeley-Jasmine Cavendish,

London

Sport’s governing bodies are to blame for allowing this. The only way they would take note would be if the other competitor­s walked back off the blocks at the start of each race. But if they did that, we know that they would be the ones punished for standing up for their own rights.

P. Cook, Wales

The other competitor­s have no choice but to compete or face claims of transphobi­a.

They’re in a lose-lose situation, and it must be very dishearten­ing for them.

U. King, Edinburgh

As if it isn’t difficult enough to be a profession­al female athlete, given their lack of funding and sponsorshi­p. Now they must face competitor­s who are bigger and stronger than them. We need to protect women’s sport and safe spaces.

Marcus Olson, Isle of Man

Sarah is right about Lia Thomas – it’s not a fair competitio­n. But

Lia obviously loves swimming and wants to be able to compete. Where can she do this? It’s actually very sad for her.

N. Davis, London

This is very brave of you, Sarah. It will be interestin­g to see what happens in response to your column. Please follow this up by reporting on the backlash I presume you are now getting.

Dave Adams, Newcastle upon Tyne

Sarah Vine is to be congratula­ted for supporting women. The Government should protect people like her and their right to free speech, as well as bringing in laws to protect women’s rights.

Name and address supplied

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom