The Scottish Mail on Sunday

CONTRASTIN­G FORTUNES OF CAPITAL CLUBS

-

LAST season, Robbie Neilson found himself under pressure after a Scottish Cup defeat to Brora Rangers.

Ultimately, the club stayed calm and ignored the supporters who were calling for him to go. That faith has been rewarded by promotion, a third-placed Premiershi­p finish and now a berth in this season’s final.

Contrast that to the turnaround in Hibs’ fortunes over the same period.

This season promised so much at Easter Road. The club was trying to build on a third-placed finish and were looking to go one better in the cups, having reached last year’s Scottish Cup final.

That’s why it was so surprising to see Jack Ross lose his job in the lead-up to the League Cup showpiece back in December.

I know Jack personally, of course. But, taking aside personal feelings, it was so disappoint­ing for me to see a fellow manager lose his job days before he was due to lead his team out in a cup final at Hampden.

Jack was deserving of that opportunit­y. His team’s performanc­e to beat Rangers in the semi-final was as good as anything I’ve seen against the Old Firm.

Tactically, they were spot on. Now they are out of the Scottish Cup and preparing for the bottom six, which is way below what was expected of them.

The results in the back-to back derbies were no surprise.

Robbie and his recruitmen­t team deserve a lot of credit for doing some good business last summer. There just seems to be a calmness and assurance about everything at Tynecastle this season. They have not been perfect, but to come up from the Championsh­ip and finish third comfortabl­y is testament to a lot of good work.

It looks like there is a plan in place and a quiet confidence about them.

And, as good a player as John Souttar is, I don’t think his departure for Rangers will derail them. Other clubs have a lot to do in the summer to get to where Hearts are now.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom