Officials’ secret talks on moving troubled ferries
I think it would be absolute lunacy to move the ships at this stage Relocation discussed after cash demands and delays
officials held discussions over moving Scotland’s two new CalMac ferries to a new shipyard to be completed.
The Sunday Post can reveal talks were held between Transport Scotland and Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd (CMAL) on the time and cost implications of such a move as part of “risk mitigation”.
The Ferguson Marine shipyard in Port Glasgow, the last commercial shipyard on the Clyde, won the £97 million contract to build the ferries in 2015.
The ferries will be the first in the world to run on a dual-fuel system using both diesel and liquefied natural gas.
But a dispute has broken out, with the yard’s owner billionaire Jim McColl threatening to take CMAL to court to pay for additional work which he said was caused by design changes made to the ferries.
CMAL, which is owned by the Scottish Government and is responsible for buying and leasing ferries for operators Calmac, has insisted the work is covered by the original contract.
In a written response to a parliamentary question from Scottish Conservative MSP Jamie Greene, finance minister Derek Mackay said: “As part of its approach to risk management mitigation, Transport Scotland had discussions with Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd on the potential time and cost implications of moving the two new ferries to an alternative location for completion.”
Gary Cook, of union GMB Scotland, said: “It would be absolute lunacy to move the ships at this stage.
“The programme is going well in terms of the catch-up process for the design process, so the expertise is in Fergusons.
“I am very confident the expertise is there and they will be completed there.”
McColl, who is an adviser to Nicola Sturgeon, helped rescue the Ferguson Marine shipyard. The contract to build the new ferries awarded by the Scottish Government gave the company vital work.
A political row was triggered when it emerged Ferguson Marine had been given a £45 million loan facility by the Scottish Government, leading to accusations of “crony capitalism”.
Any move for the work to be completed at another shipyard would be seized on by the SNP’s opponents, who have also criticised delays to the delivery of the two ships.
In September, McColl threatened legal action against CMAL, saying he required the loan only because CMAL had refused to pay for the additional work caused by design changes to the ferries.
He said: “If CMAL continue to fail to engage with us we will take them to court.
“We are very confident we have carried out additional work which CMAL, ie the Scottish government, has to pay for.
“Once we are paid we will pay back the loan to the Scottish Government.”
Jamie Greene, Scottish Conservative transport spokesman, said: “The nationalists can’t point the finger at anyone else for this.
“It’s time for them to take responsibility and ensure Scotland’s ferry fleet – so vital to various economies across the country – is fighting fit for the present and future.”
A CMAL spokeswoman said Ferguson Marine Engineering had entered into the contract with “full and prior knowledge of the specification and terms of the contract.”
She added: “CMAL fundamentally disagrees with any assertion that there have been significant changes.”
Transport Scotland refused to disclose when discussions took place.
A spokesman said: “There are no plans to move the two ferries, currently under construction at Ferguson Marine Engineering Ltd, to an alternative location.”