Should libraries scrap fines?
Some people think punishments put people off using libraries.
Has your local library scrapped library fines? During the pandemic, some libraries made it easier to borrow books: for example, by delivering books to vulnerable library users’ doorsteps. Many libraries have got rid of fines all together. Roulin Khondoker, a member of a council in London, says this change marks the “end to conflict and disputes over late fines” and makes libraries more welcoming environments. Not all librarians agree with the new rules, though. One librarian said the fine on an overdue book was not there to make money but to make sure that all library users have fair access to books. After all, some books are so popular that there can be a waiting list for people who want to read it next. So, what do you think? Should libraries stop fining people?
Yes – libraries should be free
A library’s mission is to give everyone equal access to essential services, including free access to books. People who don’t have much money really rely on libraries to help them save money, not spend it. Also, library fines could put people off from borrowing books; some people can only access books by borrowing them. Studies show that reading improves people’s education and mental wellbeing, so anything that stops people reading is bad. Libraries do more than house books. They put on events, provide people with access to other services and tools, such as computers, and create a sense of community. Libraries deserve to be properly funded by the Government, so they don’t need to fine people.
No – libraries need money to stay open
Many libraries are at risk of closing because they can’t afford the cost of operating. Charging for overdue books gives libraries an income to help them with these costs. They can also use it to improve and increase the range of books and services they provide. Besides, issuing fines is a way of discouraging people from returning books late. Without fines, people might be more relaxed and many more books could be returned late. Libraries only work if people borrowing books return them on time, ready for other library users to enjoy. Library fines are not that high anyway, and most councils cap them so they can’t go beyond a certain amount. For example, Camden Council in London charges a maximum of £5 per item.