The Week

Special offers, competitio­ns and events for readers of

Register at Theweeksoc­iety.co.uk for your special offers

-

To The Times

As Alice Thomson points out, children are being groomed to gamble online, but they are also being bombarded by gambling advertisin­g on TV. The UK gambling industry spent £312m on advertisin­g in 2016 – a 63% increase since 2012. Gambling advertisin­g on TV in the UK has increased by 43% since 2012, and a great deal is shown in the commercial breaks of live sporting events. Some 95% of TV advert breaks during live UK football matches feature at least one gambling advert.

Perhaps we should follow Australia and ban gambling advertisin­g during televised live sport as well as for a period before and after the event is shown. The inevitable consequenc­es of allowing this normalisat­ion of gambling to go unchecked will be an increase in problem gamblers, mental health issues, financial distress and family breakdown. Lord Chadlingto­n, House of Lords, London

To The Daily Telegraph

Nick Timothy is correct in saying that our whole criminal justice system is flawed, but he misses one vital point: the need for retributio­n.

Today, retributio­n is regarded as unacceptab­le, with rehabilita­tion the sine qua non, but any justice system that ignores this requiremen­t loses public support.

Our primitive ancestors understood this. Crime hurts, and the hurt is doubled if victims see the guilty free and laughing while their pain persists. But personal vengeance destroys communitie­s. Our ancestors therefore took from the individual the right to pursue their own justice in return for a contract from the community that it would avenge their hurt. For decades now, society has reneged on its side of the contract. Crimes are left uninvestig­ated and the criminals let off lightly, while the victims’ suffering persists.

The desire for retributio­n may be ignoble, but it is human and must be humanely accommodat­ed. As with John Worboys, our justice system

To The Times

Philip Collins is right that trust in immigratio­n policy needs confidence about individual identity and entitlemen­t, but all his arguments assume that Britain will remain permanentl­y dependent on large-scale migration. Immigratio­n can be beneficial if selective, but need never be massive. The present dependency is pathologic­al and unnecessar­y. The NHS is unique in Europe in depending on foreign staff since its inception, as a badly planned and poorly funded nationalis­ed industry. We can and should train most of our own.

Dependency on EU migration is new since the late 1990s. It arises from a sudden huge expansion of labour

To The Guardian

It is very dispiritin­g to see the children’s commission­er joining the ranks of politician­s, journalist­s and other commentato­rs in pointing the finger at “poor” schools to explain the “North- South divide” in secondary school educationa­l attainment.

The only significan­t divide in England is the one between London and the rest of the country. And for the few people still left interested in basing national policy on facts, there is an emphatic answer to the question, “Why are London schools so successful?” The research conducted by Professor Simon Burgess for the University of Bristol into the “London effect” showed that the difference in pupil progress, from the end of primary school to the completion of GCSES, “is entirely accounted for by ethnic compositio­n” and has been so for at least the past decade.

White British pupils have the lowest progress measure, both in London and in the rest of England. But whereas white British pupils account for about 85% of all pupils in the rest of the country, they account for only 35% in London. Or, to put it more bluntly, London schools have on average almost two-and-ahalf times fewer of the lowestperf­orming pupils as schools in the rest of England.

Teachers and head teachers in London have worked very hard over the years to raise standards, but so have their colleagues elsewhere in the country. It doesn’t help them, or their pupils and parents, to have journalist­s and politician­s, and now the children’s commission­er, ignoring the most blatantly clear evidence that the main reason why London’s schools have been so effective is a factor entirely beyond their control. Chris Dunne, retired London head teacher

 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom