Queen Victoria and Her Prime Ministers
William Collins 576pp £30
The Week Bookshop £23.99 (incl. p&p)
Elizabeth II once described her greatgreat-grandmother as a “believer in moderation in all things”, said Matthew Dennison in The Daily Telegraph. But as Anne Somerset demonstrates in this “masterly account” of Queen Victoria’s relationships with the ten men who served as her prime ministers, Victoria was “frequently far from moderate”. In her private letters and memoranda, she made clear her dislike of “vivisectionists, Russians and four-time prime minister William Ewart Gladstone” (depicted together, above). And she remained unswervingly convinced of her right to meddle in politics – railing, for instance, against the “miserable democrats” in the Liberal Party. This caused friction, inevitably. Gladstone referred to her as “the leader of the opposition”. Even the Conservative Disraeli, who was one of her favourites, found her “wilful and whimsical, like a spoilt child”.
“Victoria supposedly wrote 60 million words during her reign, or 2,500 a day,” said Gerard DeGroot in The Times. Somerset has immersed herself in this “huge mass of correspondence” – but while the result is “impressively well-researched”, she doesn’t entirely succeed in her apparent mission to “emphasise Victoria’s positive contributions”. Indeed, at one point she admits that her subject’s behaviour “verged upon the monstrous”. Covering Victoria’s 63-year reign, from 1837, the book is billed as a “personal history” – but what it really reveals is the gap between “Victoria’s public image and the queen her ministers saw”. Perhaps this gap is inevitable: “for a constitutional monarchy to work”, reverence “must be heaped on an individual who might, in truth, be a despot, a psychopath or an idiot”. Nevertheless, this account is an “eye-opener”, and Victoria’s reputation does not emerge well from it.
What we see is that Victoria “loved power”, said Philip Mansel in The Spectator. She was an enthusiastic reader of despatches. “Far from being fatigued with signatures and business, I like the whole thing exceedingly,” she wrote in 1837. She also appreciated “British patriotism, British successes”, and what she called the “deep devotion and loyalty of my people”. Despite the “tragic living conditions” of many of her subjects, she was cheered even on her last visit to Ireland in April 1900, although she couldn’t stand the Irish: “abominable… a dreadful people”. As Somerset’s “magnificent, disturbing” history reminds us, in the 19th century, “most people wanted more monarchy, not less”.