WHAT CAR? SAYS

If we were simply to add up all the stars, the M2 would win this test. But we aren’t comparing family hatchbacks; you buy a sports car for the way it drives, and here the A110 strikes a killer blow.the way it dissects a twisting B-road is something any keen driver will relish. Even when you’re not pushing on, the precise, communicative steering keeps you involved. Driving doesn’t get much more rewarding than this.

But that doesn’t mean you should ignore the M2. Not only is it faster, but it also has entertaining handling and a memorable engine.and if practicality matters at all, the M2 would be far easier to live with.

Alpine A110

For Sublime steering and handling; cheaper to run; more responsive gearbox Against Tiny boots; low-rent interior; ddly infotainment; poor rearward visibility Buy this car at whatcar.com/new-car-deals

BMW M2 Competition

For Stronger, more exible performance; characterful engine; much more practical Against Thirsty; rmer ride; feels blunt and heavy next to A110; more road noise Save £749 at whatcar.com/new-car-deals