BBC coverage of Sir Cliff raid was ‘invasion of privacy’, court is told
SIR CLIFF Richard’s lawyers have told a High Court judge that the singer should get compensation at the “very top end of the scale” because BBC coverage of a police raid on his home caused him “great damage”.
The 77-year-old singer has sued the BBC over coverage of the raid – which followed a sex assault allegation. Sir Cliff, who denied the allegation and was not charged with any offence, says he suffered “profound and long-lasting dam- age” as a result of coverage.
BBC editors have said they will “defend ourselves vigorously”.
Mr Justice Mann yesterday began overseeing a trial, expected to last 10 days, at the High Court in London.
A barrister leading Sir Cliff’s legal team told Mr Justice Mann that BBC coverage of the search at the singer’s apartment in Sunningdale, Berkshire, in August 2014 was a “very serious invasion” of privacy. Justin Rushbrooke QC told how coverage had a “prolonged impact” on Sir Cliff.
He did not give any indication of the amount Sir Cliff wanted.
But Mr Justice Mann heard that the singer had already agreed to accept a £400,000 payment from the force which carried out the search.
Sir Cliff, who was abroad when the raid took place, had initially sued the BBC and South Yorkshire Police.
Mr Justice Mann was told
in May 2017 how that dispute had been settled after the force agreed to pay the singer “substantial” damages. The judge has now been given the figure by lawyers representing the force at the trial. They explained in a written statement given to the judge how the force had in May 2017 agreed to pay Sir Cliff £400,000 and to pick up some of his lawyers’ bills.
“We think it is hard to imagine a case of publicity about a suspect in a police investigation which could have caused greater damage to the autonomy and dignity of the claimant,” said Mr Rushbrooke, “when you look at the prolonged impact it had upon Sir Cliff ’s life.”
He added: “We say this is a claim for an award at the very top end of the scale.”
Lawyers have told Mr Justice Mann how in late 2013, a man made an allegation to the Metropolitan Police, saying he had been sexually assaulted by Sir Cliff, during an event featuring evangelist Billy Graham at Sheffield United’s Bramall Lane football stadium in Sheffield, when a child in 1985.
Metropolitan Police officers passed the allegation to South Yorkshire Police in July 2014. Sir Cliff denied the allegation and in June 2016 prosecutors announced that he would face no charges. A BBC spokesman has said that the BBC had reported Sir Cliff ’s “full denial of the allegations at every stage”.
The case continues.