Offering a replay about the replay challenge rules
NSo one reader emailed that I “misused” the term “slipper y slope” and another told me I had “misappropriated” the term last week when I wrote that replay as an officiating tool is a slipper y slope.
Balderdash.
Incidentally, whether I use or misuse, appropriate or misappropriate
any term is up to me. It ’s my column, my time, my two cents’ worth — well, at least until we ban the penny. So bug off and go read The New Yorker if you crave more precise and correct use of the lang uage.
And, what, now we’re going to have replay challenges on my column? No, no, no, no, no. I write it, you read it, and we move on. I’m not going to sit here beholden to ever y Tom, Dick and Harriet googling my ever y proclamation and preposition.
I stand by my work, week in and week out. Like Andy Reid just said,
“Not all of Mozart ’s paintings were perfect.”
But I digress.
For those of you who found my “slipper y slope syndrome” explanation wanting, let me then switch replay gears and present my “small barking dog syndrome.”
Sometimes there is a small, barking dog at your ankles that keeps nipping at your pants cuff. It ’s irritating, yet not enough to do more than shake your leg occasionally to free yourself of the dog ’s grip. But then you look down several minutes later and notice that this small barking yapping irritating creature has ripped your pants leg completely wide open.
And, there, my friends, you have the basic problem of replay as an officiating tool.
So I again plead to Sports Nation — let ’s return to kinder, simpler prereplay days.
( People often fault me for “liv ing in the past.” Uh, I can’t can I? I am the product of two centuries; both have their merits and their f laws. Alas, replay as an officiating tool was mindlessly birthed in the 20th centur y and is reaching its devastating potential in the 21st centur y. Then again, since I have serious doubts if there will be a 22nd centur y, this problem might solve itself.)
Many people think officiating, particularly in the NFL and the NBA, is worse than ever; it ’s not. The officials are just scrutinized more than ever.
Do you think there was replay review when the games used to be only on radio?
Are games harder to officiate now because athletes are bigger, stronger and faster? Maybe. But it ’s definitely harder to officiate when millions are officiating alongside you. There are even websites, like footballzebras. com, that assess and review officials’ calls 24- 7.
Trust me, it would not be half as f un being an actuar y if ever y line of your work were under replay review.
And when’s the last time you saw, say, a ballet or an opera stopped because of a replay challenge? Man, those would be momentum killers — for instance, “La Boheme” would lose all of its steam if, just before Mimi’s climactic coughing fit, Schaunard questions the receipt on the pink bonnet that Rodolpho has bought for her and throws the challenge f lag.
The fact of the matter is, there are fouls and penalties committed on virtually ever y possession in basketball, football and life.
If you whistled ever y foul in the NBA by the book, ever y player would foul out.
If you called ever y holding by an offensive lineman or ever y pass interference, NFL games would take f ive hours.
If you held a U. S. president accountable for ever y high crime and misdemeanor committed while in the Oval Office, we wouldn’t have a president.
Sometimes — particularly on the field of play — you just have to let stuff go.
( Best I can tell, the major professional sport least affected at this point by replay is hockey. So, maybe, just maybe — I know I’m going to regret this — NHL, here I come! When does the reg ular season start?)
Ask The Slouch
When the Chicago Bears announced Mitch Trubisky injured his “non- throwing shoulder,” did your finely honed journalism instincts lead you to ask if the team could be more specific? ( Jeremy Sandler; Toronto) a: Pay the man, Shirley.
Q: Even the slightest improvement in equipment can give an athlete a competitive advantage. Shouldn’t some company start making under wear for left- handed men? ( Jack Leininger; Spokane, Wash.) a: Pay the man, Shirley.
Q: Do you have any insight as to whether NBA referee Scott Foster is the “whistleblower ” that President Trump is looking for? ( Elliott Jaffa; Arling ton, Va.) a: Pay the man, Shirley.
Q: Do you miss when the Washington R* dsk* ns used to win the offseason? I mean, it was a win. ( Mike Garland; Washington, D. C.)
a: Pay the man, Shirley.