Conviction in teen’s death may be tough
Jurors reluctant to second-guess officers
HOUSTON — Authorities who have charged a white suburban Dallas police officer with murder in a black teenager’s death face a tough task in getting a conviction, since few of these cases go to trial and, when they do, juries remain reluctant to second guess an officer’s decision to use deadly force, legal experts said Saturday.
Roy Oliver is free on bond after being charged Friday in the death of 15-year-old Jordan Edwards. Investigators say Oliver shot into a car of teenagers leaving an unruly party on April 29, killing Edwards. Oliver was fired by the Balch Springs Police Department three days after the shooting.
Philip Stinson, a criminal justice professor at Bowling Green State University in Ohio, said data he has collected since 2005 on police shootings shows that officers are rarely charged in deadly shootings. It’s even rarer for an officer to be convicted, according to the data.
From his research, Stinson estimates that fatal shootings by U.S. police officers who are on duty occur about 1,000 times a year. But since 2005, only 81 officers have been charged with murder or manslaughter resulting from an on-duty shooting, he said. Of these 81 cases, 30 ended with convictions, 31 cases with no conviction and 20 are pending.
In recent years, many police shootings have been captured on video taken by officers’ body cameras or witnesses’ cellphones. But Stinson said such evidence still doesn’t guarantee a conviction.
He points to the 2015 shooting in South Carolina of black motorist Walter Scott by officer Michael Slager. A cellphone video captured Slager’s shooting Scott five times in the back as the unarmed 50-year-old man ran away during a traffic stop. In December, a mistrial was declared in Slager’s murder trial after a jury couldn’t reach a verdict.
A private funeral service for Edwards was held on Saturday.